{"data":[{"attachment_id":"aca2c46c-81e7-4d06-a469-fb4b6726ec44","title":"Presentation (November 12, 2026)","version":1,"status":"published","authored_at":"2026-11-16T14:24:09.173Z","change_kind":"initial","change_note":"1 statement withheld: c2: Page 4 specifies 21 years as a luthier, while record:description states over 40 years crafting musical instruments without specifying luthier tenure, so identical scope and a conflict are not established.","analysis":{"claims":[{"id":"c1","note":"","text":"The slides say the appointment would fill all vacant Noise Review Board seats.","quote":"With this appointment, the Noise\nReview Board membership will have\nall vacant seats filled.","locator":"page 5","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"With this appointment, the Noise Review Board membership will have all vacant seats filled.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c3","note":"","text":"The slides say the candidate has 40 years of construction and woodworking experience as a furniture maker.","quote":"40 years of construction and woodworking experience as\na furniture maker","locator":"page 4","verdict":"unsourced","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c4","note":"","text":"The slides say the candidate served on the NRB-PIR sub-committee from 2021 to 2023 to study noise impacts from Portland International Raceway.","quote":"2021 to 2023, served on the NRB-PIR sub-committee, formed to\nstudy the noise impacts of Portland International Raceway","locator":"page 4","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"served from 2021 to 2023, on the NRB - PIR sub-committee which was formed to study the noise impacts of Portland International Raceway.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c5","note":"","text":"The slides say the candidate served on the Noise Advisory Workgroup from 2023 to 2025 to help refine, improve and craft amendments for Title 18.","quote":"2023 to 2025, served on the Noise Advisory Workgroup, formed to\nhelp refine, improve and craft amendments for Title 18","locator":"page 4","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"Subsequently from 2023 to 2025, he served on the Noise Advisory Workgroup, a selected group of volunteers with experience around acoustics and noise, formed to help refine, improve and craft proposed amendments to Title 18, aka City Noise Code","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c6","note":"","text":"The slides say the board has five members: three community members, a construction industry representative and an acoustics professional.","quote":"Composed of five members:\n• Three community members-at-large\n• A representative from the construction industry\n• An acoustics professional","locator":"page 2","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"The Noise Review Board is comprised of five members, including three community member-at-large positions, a representative from the construction industry, and a professional in the field of acoustics.","locator":"impact:purpose","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c7","note":"","text":"The slides say the board reviews and approves noise variances for large events and construction projects.","quote":"This is a quasi-judicial board that responsible for reviewing and\napproving noise variances for large events and construction\nprojects that may have significant impact.","locator":"page 2","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"In accordance with Title 18, the Noise Review Board is charged with making decisions on noise variances for projects that range from nighttime construction projects to large outdoor concerts.","locator":"impact:purpose","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c8","note":"","text":"The slides say the Noise Review Board was established in 1987.","quote":"Established in 1987, the Noise Review Board is an advisory\nbody of appointed volunteers","locator":"page 2","verdict":"unsourced","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c9","note":"","text":"The slides say board members may serve two terms.","quote":"Members are appointed by the Mayor and approved by City\nCouncil, for a three-year term and may serve two terms.","locator":"page 2","verdict":"unsourced","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c10","note":"","text":"The slides say the candidate volunteered as a driving coach for the youth driving school \"Street Survival\" at Portland Raceway and for Cascade Sports Car Club.","quote":"Volunteered as a driving coach at Portland Raceway for the youth\ndriving school \"Street Survival\", and for Cascade Sports Car Club","locator":"page 4","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"has also volunteered as a coach at Portland Raceway for the youth driving school \"Street Survival\", as well as being a driving coach for Cascade Sports Car Club.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null}],"summary":[{"id":"s1","text":"This is a Portland Permitting & Development presentation about a Noise Review Board member appointment.","citations":[{"quote":"Noise Review Board\nMember Appointment","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-aca2c46c-81e"},{"quote":"Portland Permitting & Development","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-aca2c46c-81e"}]},{"id":"s2","text":"The slides say the proposed appointment would fill all vacant seats, with a term running Dec. 2, 2026 – Dec. 1, 2029.","citations":[{"quote":"term will run Dec. 2, 2026 – Dec. 1,\n2029.","locator":"page 5","sourceId":"file-aca2c46c-81e"},{"quote":"With this appointment, the Noise\nReview Board membership will have\nall vacant seats filled.","locator":"page 5","sourceId":"file-aca2c46c-81e"}]},{"id":"s3","text":"The presentation asks for referral to the full Council for approval.","citations":[{"quote":"We appreciate your support in\nreferring this appointment to the full\nCouncil for approval.","locator":"page 5","sourceId":"file-aca2c46c-81e"}]}]},"prompt_version":"file-check-v1","model":"gpt-6-astra","authored_by":"codex_subscription_verified","is_current":true}],"notice":"Automated summaries and source checks by Portland Civic Lab. No person reviewed them before publication. Labels compare a file with the rest of the official record and do not judge whether a statement is true. Replaced and withdrawn versions are retained."}