{"data":[{"attachment_id":"cccd1638-6ca6-4400-b6b1-c4c2db8313e0","title":"Approved amendment – Green/Pirtle-Guiney/Kanal/Clark/Koyama Lane 2 (October 1, 2026)","version":1,"status":"published","authored_at":"2026-11-17T16:26:12.074Z","change_kind":"initial","change_note":"1 statement withheld: c1: The cited label is not established: page 1 references Figure 3.10, which the record’s description identifies as the project’s Comprehensive Plan map, rather than an outside source for the percentage.","analysis":{"claims":[{"id":"c2","note":"","text":"The amendment says the hub sits on liquefiable soils in an area exposed to natural hazards, posing significant accident or earthquake risks.","quote":"The CEI Hub is located on liquefiable soils in an area subject to natural hazards,\nposing significant risk in the event of an accident or earthquake.","locator":"page 1","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"Numerous studies have found that the concentration of bulk fuel terminals in the CEI Hub presents\nsignificant risks, primarily due to the CEI Hub’s location on land with a high risk of liquefaction. In the\nevent of a major earthquake, particularly a Cascadia Subduction Zone (CSZ) event, storage tanks in the\nCEI Hub are likely to fail, releasing fuel and other hazardous materials. Such a disaster would pose\nserious threats to human health and to the environment, including waterways, air quality, and adjacent\nnatural areas.","locator":"page 15","sourceId":"file-164c5ae2-808"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c3","note":"","text":"The amendment says BPS proposed three review systems.","quote":"Description: Establishes two review criteria systems, replacing the three review systems\nproposed by BPS:","locator":"page 5","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"The zoning code amendments also create three Bulk Fuel Terminal Reviews under which approval may be granted for: expansion of existing or creation of new transloading facilities; a limited increase in aviation fuel storage capacity; and the transfer of storage tank capacity from one terminal to another.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":"BPS"}],"summary":[{"id":"s1","text":"The approved amendment attributed to Green, Pirtle-Guiney, Kanal, Clark and Koyama Lane changes city planning policies and fuel-terminal zoning rules as part of the adopted ordinance.","citations":[{"quote":"Amendment – Green/Pirtle-Guiney/Kanal/Clark/Koyama Lane 2\nComprehensive Plan Amendments","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-cccd1638-6ca"},{"quote":"Title 33 Zoning Code Amendments","locator":"page 2","sourceId":"file-cccd1638-6ca"}]},{"id":"s2","text":"It supports finding alternative locations for fuel facilities and broadens public notification of terminal projects.","citations":[{"quote":"3.83.c. Economic Significance. Recognize the important vital role the CEI Hub currently plays in\nthe local and state economy and support efforts to identify alternative locations for these\nfacilities in recognition of the ongoing economic risk of concentrating bulk fuel facilities in a\nnatural hazard risk area.","locator":"page 2","sourceId":"file-cccd1638-6ca"},{"quote":"Description: Adds additional neighborhoods impacted by activity at the Hub to subsection (B),\nadds (C) as a form of public notification, adds (D) as a technical header to contextualize (D)1-4,\nand clarifies the instances when notifications specified in (B) and (C) are triggered.","locator":"page 3","sourceId":"file-cccd1638-6ca"}]},{"id":"s3","text":"It establishes separate reviews for replacing tanks and expanding storage, with safety requirements and limits on capacity.","citations":[{"quote":"Fuel Storage Tank Replacement Review – Allows existing bulk fuel terminals to replace\naging storage tanks in order to improve safety and seismic resilience. Approval is\nconditioned on building the new tank to high seismic standards, maintaining compliance\nwith state risk mitigation requirements, not increasing site risk, and removing at least an\nequivalent amount of old tank capacity.","locator":"page 5","sourceId":"file-cccd1638-6ca"},{"quote":"Fuel Storage Tank Capacity Expansion Review – Allows limited expansion or\nreconfiguration of fuel storage capacity at existing terminals only when there is a\ndemonstrated need and clear public benefit. Expansion must not increase overall fuel\nstorage capacity across the CEI Hub (with a narrow aviation exception), and must meet\nstrict safety, seismic, environmental, and risk mitigation standards.","locator":"page 5","sourceId":"file-cccd1638-6ca"}]}]},"prompt_version":"file-check-v1","model":"gpt-6-astra","authored_by":"codex_subscription_verified","is_current":true},{"attachment_id":"b7041478-07f6-4514-b286-d1780566bcda","title":"Failed amendment - Green 1 (October 1, 2026)","version":1,"status":"published","authored_at":"2026-11-17T16:27:14.580Z","change_kind":"initial","change_note":"Every sentence and label passed the quotation checks and the independent review.","analysis":{"claims":[],"summary":[{"id":"s1","text":"This failed amendment, labeled Green-1, presents two versions of a rule for approving expansions at the CEI Hub.","citations":[{"quote":"Green-1 Version 1:\n33.870.060 Approval Criteria","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-b7041478-07f"},{"quote":"Green-1 Version 2:\n33.870.060 Approval Criteria","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-b7041478-07f"}]},{"id":"s2","text":"The first would prevent expansions from increasing total in-service fuel storage or fuel-transfer capacity above January 1, 2027 levels.","citations":[{"quote":"C. The expansion will not result in an increase in the total in-service fuel storage tank\ncapacity or transloading capacity that existed within the CEI Hub on January 1, 2027;","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-b7041478-07f"}]},{"id":"s3","text":"The second would allow an exception for aviation fuel storage, permitting capacity up to 5 percent above the storage capacity on the applicant’s site on January 1, 2027.","citations":[{"quote":"unless\nthe expansion is for the storage of aviation fuel. If the expansion is for the storage of\naviation fuel, the total amount of expanded storage tank capacity cannot exceed 5 percent\nmore than the storage tank capacity that existed on the applicant’s site on January 1, 2027;","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-b7041478-07f"}]}]},"prompt_version":"file-check-v1","model":"gpt-6-astra","authored_by":"codex_subscription_verified","is_current":true},{"attachment_id":"860b8811-0b3c-4cae-9934-86612110ed6c","title":"Ordinance - as amended","version":1,"status":"published","authored_at":"2026-11-16T15:28:49.697Z","change_kind":"initial","change_note":"Every sentence and label passed the quotation checks and the independent review.","analysis":{"claims":[{"id":"c1","note":"","text":"The ordinance says the hub receives 90 percent of Oregon's liquid fuel supply through pipelines or marine vessels.","quote":"The CEI Hub, which consists of Oregon's primary liquid fuel storage and\ndistribution facilities, receives 90 percent of the state's liquid fuel supply either\nvia pipeline or marine vessel.","locator":"page 1","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"The CEI Hub, which consists of Oregon's primary liquid fuel storage and distribution facilities, receives 90 percent of the state's liquid fuel supply either via pipeline or marine vessel.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c2","note":"","text":"The ordinance says most hub fuel tanks were built before Oregon adopted seismic design requirements in its building codes in 1993.","quote":"Most of the fuel storage tanks within the CEI Hub\nwere built before seismic design requirements in Oregon’s building codes were\nadopted in 1993.","locator":"page 1","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"Most of the fuel storage tanks within the CEI Hub were built before seismic design requirements in Oregon's building codes were adopted in 1993.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c3","note":"","text":"The ordinance says the hub contains eleven (11) bulk fuel terminals and faces hazards from liquefiable soils, wildfire and landslides.","quote":"The Critical Energy Infrastructure (CEI) Hub in northwest Portland consists of\neleven (11) bulk fuel terminals and the area is subject to multiple natural\nhazards, including liquefiable soils, wildfire and landslides.","locator":"page 1","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"The Critical Energy Infrastructure (CEI) Hub in northwest Portland consists of eleven (11) bulk fuel terminals and the area is subject to multiple natural hazards, including liquefiable soils, wildfire and landslides.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c4","note":"","text":"The ordinance says the hub and its bulk fuel terminals are vulnerable to failure during a subduction zone earthquake.","quote":"The CEI Hub, and bulk fuel terminals therein, are vulnerable to failure in the\nevent of subduction zone earthquake.","locator":"page 1","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"In the\nevent of a major earthquake, particularly a Cascadia Subduction Zone (CSZ) event, storage tanks in the\nCEI Hub are likely to fail, releasing fuel and other hazardous materials.","locator":"page 15","sourceId":"file-164c5ae2-808"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c5","note":"","text":"The ordinance says the earthquake risk study found that only three existing storage tanks were known to have addressed liquefaction vulnerabilities at the time.","quote":"The study also notes that, at the time,\nonly three existing storage tanks were known to have addressed liquefaction\nvulnerabilities.","locator":"page 2","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"The study also notes that, at the time, only three existing storage tanks were known to have addressed liquefaction vulnerabilities.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c6","note":"","text":"The ordinance says transloading facilities and expansion of renewable and aviation fuel storage capacity are not currently regulated.","quote":"The CEI Hub Policy Project amendments will regulate transloading facilities and\nthe expansion of renewable and aviation fuel storage tank capacity, which are\nnot currently regulated.","locator":"page 3","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"The CEI Hub Policy Project amendments will regulate transloading facilities and the expansion of renewable and aviation fuel storage tank capacity, which are not currently regulated.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c7","note":"","text":"The ordinance says 2022 rules prohibited new bulk fossil fuel terminals and limited added fossil fuel storage capacity at existing terminals, with exceptions for aviation and renewable fuels.","quote":"In 2022, Ordinance 190978 adopted amendments to Title 33, Planning and\nZoning, that prohibited new bulk fossil fuel terminals within the City of Portland\nand placed limits on new fossil fuel storage tank capacity at existing terminals\nexcept for storage for aviation and renewable fuels.","locator":"page 3","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"In 2022, Ordinance 190978 adopted amendments to Title 33, Planning and Zoning, that prohibited new bulk fossil fuel terminals within the City of Portland and placed limits on new fossil fuel storage tank capacity at existing terminals except for storage for aviation and renewable fuels.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c8","note":"","text":"The ordinance says most Portland industrial districts, particularly those with river access, are in areas with a high probability of liquefaction.","quote":"Most of Portland's industrial districts, especially those areas with river access,\nare located in areas with a high probability of liquefaction, as documented by the\n2018 DOGAMI Earthquake Regional Impact Analysis.","locator":"page 2","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"Most of Portland's industrial districts, especially those areas with river access, are located in areas with a high probability of liquefaction, as documented by the 2018 DOGAMI Earthquake Regional Impact Analysis.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c9","note":"","text":"The ordinance says the City received a FEMA grant in 2023 to strengthen zoning restrictions and natural-hazard policies for fuel terminals.","quote":"In 2023 the City received a Hazard Mitigation Grant Program grant from the\nUnited States Department of Homeland Security’s Federal Emergency\nManagement Agency (FEMA) “to adopt additional zoning code restrictions on\nfossil fuel terminals so that the energy infrastructure of Portland will be more\nseismically resilient, and to amend the natural hazard policies in the 2035\nComprehensive Plan to provide a stronger policy foundation for these actions.”","locator":"page 3","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"In 2023 the City received a Hazard Mitigation Grant Program grant from the United States Department of Homeland Security's Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) \"to adopt additional zoning code restrictions on fossil fuel terminals so that the energy infrastructure of Portland will be more seismically resilient, and to amend the natural hazard policies in the 2035 Comprehensive Plan to provide a stronger policy foundation for these actions.\"","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c10","note":"","text":"The ordinance says staff received over 850 written public comments on the discussion draft.","quote":"On September 16, 2025, the CEI Hub Policy Project Discussion Draft was\nreleased for public review, and comments were accepted through October 17,\n2025. StaƯ received over 850 written public comments.","locator":"page 5","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"On September 16, 2025, the CEI Hub Policy Project Discussion Draft was released for public review, and comments were accepted through October 17, 2025. Staff received over 850 written public comments.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null}],"summary":[{"id":"s1","text":"This amended City of Portland ordinance addresses health and natural-hazard risks at the Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub; the item is adopted.","citations":[{"quote":"Adopt the Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub Policy Project to support public health\nand natural hazards risk reduction. (Amend City Code Title 33 and Title 24)\nThe City of Portland ordains:","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-860b8811-0b3"}]},{"id":"s2","text":"It sets tighter limits on fuel storage expansion and regulates facilities that transfer fuel between transport modes.","citations":[{"quote":"The CEI Hub Policy Project amendments will regulate transloading facilities and\nthe expansion of renewable and aviation fuel storage tank capacity, which are\nnot currently regulated.","locator":"page 3","sourceId":"file-860b8811-0b3"}]},{"id":"s3","text":"It also directs the City Administrator to submit a work program for developing limits on non-fuel hazardous materials stored at bulk fuel terminals.","citations":[{"quote":"The City Administrator shall submit to Council a work program for the development of a\nrecommended regulatory approach to limit the storage of non-fuel hazardous materials\nat the Bulk Fuel Terminals.","locator":"page 7","sourceId":"file-860b8811-0b3"}]}]},"prompt_version":"file-check-v1","model":"gpt-6-astra","authored_by":"codex_subscription_verified","is_current":true},{"attachment_id":"fe24e49b-b5a9-4f16-b53a-a9e7778b7660","title":"Presentation (October 1, 2026)","version":1,"status":"published","authored_at":"2026-11-18T02:21:17.101Z","change_kind":"initial","change_note":"1 statement withheld: c1: The cited record description states that the Hub receives 90% of Oregon’s liquid fuel supply, while Exhibit B page 13 describes more than 90% stored and passing through, so neither establishes the exact quantity and activity claimed.","analysis":{"claims":[{"id":"c2","note":"","text":"The slides say the CEI Hub sits on liquefiable soils and poses significant earthquake risk.","quote":"The CEI Hub is located\non liquefiable soils in an area subject to natural hazards, posing significant risk\nin the event of an accident or earthquake.","locator":"page 6","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"Numerous studies have found that the concentration of bulk fuel terminals in the CEI Hub presents\nsignificant risks, primarily due to the CEI Hub’s location on land with a high risk of liquefaction. In the\nevent of a major earthquake, particularly a Cascadia Subduction Zone (CSZ) event, storage tanks in the\nCEI Hub are likely to fail, releasing fuel and other hazardous materials.","locator":"page 15","sourceId":"file-164c5ae2-808"}],"sourceNamed":null}],"summary":[{"id":"s1","text":"This City Council presentation from the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability discusses the Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub Policy Project.","citations":[{"quote":"CEI Hub Policy Project\nCity Council Meeting\nOctober 1, 2026\nEric Engstrom\nDirector\nBureau of Planning\nand Sustainability","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-fe24e49b-b5a"},{"quote":"The Critical Energy Infrastructure (CEI) Hub","locator":"page 6","sourceId":"file-fe24e49b-b5a"}]},{"id":"s2","text":"The slides outline proposed limits on fuel storage and transfer infrastructure, plus building permits for pipe supports.","citations":[{"quote":"• Amend and add Comprehensive Plan policies\n• Title 33 limits on storage tank capacity and transloading infrastructure\n• Title 24 requirements building permit for piping structural support","locator":"page 2","sourceId":"file-fe24e49b-b5a"}]},{"id":"s3","text":"They also describe a separate capacity reduction program with 2027 reporting and a 2036 reduction requirement.","citations":[{"quote":"Ordinance #2\nTitle 17 Capacity Reduction Program\n• 2027 Inventory and Fuel Volume reporting requirement\n• 2036 reduction requirement","locator":"page 2","sourceId":"file-fe24e49b-b5a"}]}]},"prompt_version":"file-check-v1","model":"gpt-6-astra","authored_by":"codex_subscription_verified","is_current":true},{"attachment_id":"0a48bee0-444c-4402-9b12-3f8ff065e304","title":"Presentation (September 24, 2026)","version":1,"status":"published","authored_at":"2026-11-18T04:29:09.564Z","change_kind":"initial","change_note":"Every sentence and label passed the quotation checks and the independent review.","analysis":{"claims":[{"id":"c1","note":"","text":"The slides say existing zoning rules prohibit new bulk fossil fuel terminals.","quote":"Existing Title 33 Zoning Code (2022 amendments)\na. Prohibits new bulk fossil fuel\nterminals","locator":"page 10","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"In 2022, Ordinance 190978 adopted amendments to Title 33, Planning and Zoning, that prohibited new bulk fossil fuel terminals within the City of Portland and placed limits on new fossil fuel storage tank capacity at existing terminals except for storage for aviation and renewable fuels.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c2","note":"","text":"The slides say existing zoning rules allow unlimited expansion for aviation and renewable fuels.","quote":"c. Allows unlimited expansion for\naviation and renewable fuels","locator":"page 10","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"The CEI Hub Policy Project amendments will regulate transloading facilities and the expansion of renewable and aviation fuel storage tank capacity, which are not currently regulated.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c3","note":"","text":"The slides say existing zoning rules allow unlimited expansion of infrastructure used to transfer fuel between transportation modes.","quote":"d. Allows unlimited expansion of\ntransloading infrastructure","locator":"page 10","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"The CEI Hub Policy Project amendments will regulate transloading facilities and the expansion of renewable and aviation fuel storage tank capacity, which are not currently regulated.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c4","note":"","text":"The slides say existing zoning rules limit existing bulk fossil fuel terminals to their 2022 fossil fuel storage capacity.","quote":"b. Limits existing bulk fossil fuel\nterminals to 2022 fossil fuel storage\ncapacity","locator":"page 10","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Title 33 Zoning Code"},{"id":"c5","note":"","text":"The slides say fire regulations require permits to install piping carrying combustible, flammable or hazardous materials.","quote":"This amendment will match the scope of Title 31, Fire Regulations, which require fire\npermits to install piping carrying combustible, flammable or hazardous materials.","locator":"page 12","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Title 31, Fire Regulations"},{"id":"c6","note":"","text":"The slides say existing zoning rules allow repair, replacement and reconfiguration of storage tanks.","quote":"e. Allows for repair, replacement and\nreconfiguration of storage tanks","locator":"page 10","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Title 33 Zoning Code"}],"summary":[{"id":"s1","text":"This City Council presentation identifies its presenters as staff from the Bureau of Planning and Sustainability.","citations":[{"quote":"CEI Hub Policy Project\nCity Council Meeting\nSeptember 24, 2026\nEric Engstrom\nDirector\nBureau of Planning\nand Sustainability\nPatricia Diefenderfer\nChief Planner\nBureau of Planning\nand Sustainability\nTom Armstrong\nSupervising Planner\nBureau of Planning\nand Sustainability","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-0a48bee0-444"}]},{"id":"s2","text":"The slides recommend limiting expansion of fuel storage and fuel-transfer infrastructure while continuing to allow repairs, replacement and reconfiguration.","citations":[{"quote":"Recommended Zoning Code Changes (Title 33)\na. Limit the expansion of storage tank capacity for all fuel types.\n Type III land use review for transfer of capacity between terminals\n Type III land use review for 5% expansion of aviation fuel capacity\nb. Limit the expansion of transloading infrastructure for all fuel types.\n Type III land use review for expansion of transloading infrastructure\nc. Continue allowing repair, replacement and reconfiguration of existing storage\ntanks and transloading infrastructure.","locator":"page 11","sourceId":"file-0a48bee0-444"}]},{"id":"s3","text":"The slides also describe a proposed 20% reduction in active fuel storage capacity by December 1, 2036, based on 2027 capacity, with exemptions.","citations":[{"quote":"Title 17 Capacity Reduction Regulations\na. Capacity reduction requirement\nBy December 1, 2036, all terminals must reduce in-service fuel storage capacity by 20% of\ntheir 2027 in-service capacity.\nb. Exemptions from reduction requirements\nRegulated utilities (NW Natural), Aviation Fuel, Approved Type III reviews","locator":"page 14","sourceId":"file-0a48bee0-444"}]}]},"prompt_version":"file-check-v1","model":"gpt-6-astra","authored_by":"codex_subscription_verified","is_current":true},{"attachment_id":"4a753014-a519-4543-9118-18e54324e922","title":"Recommended Draft Conforming and Technical Amendments Memo - original, see updated version","version":1,"status":"published","authored_at":"2026-11-16T20:33:21.138Z","change_kind":"initial","change_note":"Every sentence and label passed the quotation checks and the independent review.","analysis":{"claims":[{"id":"c1","note":"","text":"The memo says City Council approved Title 33 amendments on October 1, 2026.","quote":"2. Technical and conforming amendments necessary to align the CEI Hub Policy Project\nrecommended Title 33 zoning code with the Title 33 amendments that were approved by City\nCouncil on October 1, 2026; and","locator":"page 1","verdict":"unsourced","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":null}],"summary":[{"id":"s1","text":"This memo from supervising planner Tom Armstrong proposes wording changes to planning policies and zoning rules for the Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub.","citations":[{"quote":"FROM: Tom Armstrong, Supervising Planner\nSUBJECT: Ordinance 2026-311: Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub Policy Project Recommended Draft\nConforming and Technical Amendments\nThis memo contains:\n1. Technical amendments that clarify the wording of two Comprehensive Plan policies;\n2. Technical and conforming amendments necessary to align the CEI Hub Policy Project\nrecommended Title 33 zoning code with the Title 33 amendments that were approved by City\nCouncil on October 1, 2026; and","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-4a753014-a51"}]},{"id":"s2","text":"The proposed amendments would allow aviation fuel storage expansion through a review, capped at 5 percent of the storage capacity on the applicant’s site at adoption.","citations":[{"quote":"If the expansion is for the storage of aviation fuel, the\ntotal amount of expanded storage tank capacity cannot exceed 5 percent more than the storage tank\ncapacity that existed on the applicant’s site on [INSERT ORDINANCE ADOPTION DATE], plus\ntransloading facilities necessary to connect the expanded storage tank capacity to the terminal;","locator":"page 4","sourceId":"file-4a753014-a51"}]},{"id":"s3","text":"The memo also says the draft incorporates updated fuel-demand analysis.","citations":[{"quote":"Exhibit B CEI Hub Policy Project Recommended Draft has been updated as shown in the BPS 2026\nUpdate of Fuel Demand Analysis Supplemental Memo dated September 16, 2026","locator":"page 4","sourceId":"file-4a753014-a51"}]}]},"prompt_version":"file-check-v1","model":"gpt-6-astra","authored_by":"codex_subscription_verified","is_current":true},{"attachment_id":"4d174b6a-e7b2-4242-84d5-b9cb8157bebf","title":"Recommended Draft Conforming and Technical Amendments Memo - updated","version":1,"status":"published","authored_at":"2026-11-16T16:22:57.337Z","change_kind":"initial","change_note":"Every sentence and label passed the quotation checks and the independent review.","analysis":{"claims":[{"id":"c1","note":"","text":"The memo says City Council approved Title 33 amendments on October 1, 2026.","quote":"2. Technical and conforming amendments necessary to align the CEI Hub Policy Project\nrecommended Title 33 zoning code with the Title 33 amendments that were approved by City\nCouncil on October 1, 2026; and","locator":"page 1","verdict":"unsourced","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":null}],"summary":[{"id":"s1","text":"This memo from supervising planner Tom Armstrong proposes technical changes to city planning policies and zoning rules for bulk fuel terminals.","citations":[{"quote":"FROM: Tom Armstrong, Supervising Planner\nSUBJECT: Ordinance 2026-311: Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub Policy Project Recommended Draft\nConforming and Technical Amendments\nThis memo contains:\n1. Technical amendments that clarify the wording of two Comprehensive Plan policies;\n2. Technical and conforming amendments necessary to align the CEI Hub Policy Project\nrecommended Title 33 zoning code with the Title 33 amendments that were approved by City\nCouncil on October 1, 2026; and","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-4d174b6a-e7b"}]},{"id":"s2","text":"The amendments would allow new fuel storage tanks through replacement or expansion reviews.","citations":[{"quote":"(1) Adding a new fuel storage tank to a site is allowed when the new tank will replace an\nexisting tank on the site and the new fuel storage tank has been approved through a\nFuel Storage Tank Replacement review. See 33.870, Bulk Fuel Terminal Reviews; and\n(2) Adding a new fuel storage tank to a site is allowed when the new tank has been\napproved through a Fuel Storage Tank and Transloading Capacity Expansion Review. See\n33.870, Bulk Fuel Terminal Reviews.","locator":"page 3","sourceId":"file-4d174b6a-e7b"}]},{"id":"s3","text":"The memo also says the recommended draft was updated using a supplemental fuel-demand analysis and a replacement modeling appendix.","citations":[{"quote":"Exhibit B CEI Hub Policy Project Recommended Draft has been updated as shown in the BPS 2026\nUpdate of Fuel Demand Analysis Supplemental Memo dated September 16, 2026\nExhibit B, Appendix C is replaced with the 2026 CEI Hub Parametrix Model Update.","locator":"page 5","sourceId":"file-4d174b6a-e7b"}]}]},"prompt_version":"file-check-v1","model":"gpt-6-astra","authored_by":"codex_subscription_verified","is_current":true},{"attachment_id":"a8cc1929-26ae-4baa-9643-c88f2b61f479","title":"Supplemental Information - Green and Pirtle-Guiney (September 24, 2026)","version":1,"status":"published","authored_at":"2026-11-18T04:25:28.913Z","change_kind":"initial","change_note":"Every sentence and label passed the quotation checks and the independent review.","analysis":{"claims":[{"id":"c1","note":"","text":"The slides describe the original proposal as requiring a 20% reduction in tank capacity by 2036.","quote":"From 17.112.050.B Bulk Fuel Storage Capacity Reduction. One-time 20%\nacross-the-board reduction in tank shell capacity by 2036.","locator":"page 57","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"Other city code amendments will require a 20 percent fuel storage capacity reduction (“drawdown”) by\n2036 at each bulk fuel terminal in the CEI Hub","locator":"page 12","sourceId":"file-164c5ae2-808"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c2","note":"","text":"The document’s wording correction says 90% of Oregon’s liquid fuel supply passes through the CEI Hub’s bulk fuel terminals.","quote":"Portland’s Critical Energy Infrastructure\nHub (CEI Hub) is high-risk infrastructure because 90% of Oregon’s liquid fuel supply\npasses through the bulk fuel terminals","locator":"page 3","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"The CEI Hub, which consists of Oregon's primary liquid fuel storage and distribution facilities, receives 90 percent of the state's liquid fuel supply either via pipeline or marine vessel.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c3","note":"","text":"The slides say the CEI Hub’s fuel terminals sit on liquefiable soils exposed to multiple natural hazards.","quote":"bulk fuel terminals located on\nhigh-risk liquefiable soils subject to multiple natural hazards along the\nCity's NW waterfront.","locator":"page 48","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"The Critical Energy Infrastructure (CEI) Hub in northwest Portland consists of eleven (11) bulk fuel terminals and the area is subject to multiple natural hazards, including liquefiable soils, wildfire and landslides.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c4","note":"","text":"The document says DEQ’s FTSS program regulates CEI Hub fuels by flammability and volatility rather than feedstock or end use.","quote":"DEQ’s FTSS program\nenumerates and regulates CEI Hub fuels based on their chemical properties of flammability and volatility, not\npiecemeal by feedstock or end-use.","locator":"page 24","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"DEQ’s FTSS program"},{"id":"c5","note":"","text":"The slides say the proposed zoning rules contain Three separate review processes.","quote":"From: 33.870: Three disconnected review protocols","locator":"page 53","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"The amendments to Title 33 include three new land use reviews related to bulk fuel terminals.","locator":"impact:financial","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c6","note":"","text":"The document says LUBA sent a decision back to the City in 2022 because Comprehensive Plan language was aspirational rather than mandatory.","quote":"CEI Hub policies should not reproduce the legal weakness identified in 2022 when LUBA remanded a\ndecision to the City because it found the Comprehensive Plan “hortatory or aspirational, not mandatory or\nprohibitory.”","locator":"page 2","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"LUBA"},{"id":"c7","note":"","text":"The staff analysis says Statewide Planning Goal 9 requires local policies to provide adequate opportunities for economic activities vital to Oregon residents.","quote":"Statewide Planning Goal 9 which requires local governments to demonstrate that policies comply with\nthe requirement “to provide adequate opportunities throughout the state for a variety of economic activities vital to the health,\nwelfare, and prosperity of Oregon citizens”","locator":"page 30","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Statewide Planning Goal 9"},{"id":"c8","note":"","text":"The staff analysis says Statewide Planning Goal 12 requires cities to provide and encourage a safe, convenient and economic transportation system.","quote":"Statewide Planning Goal 12 which requires cities “to provide and encourage a\nsafe, convenient and economic transportation system.”","locator":"page 30","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Statewide Planning Goal 12"},{"id":"c9","note":"The recommendation says “support” is absent from the glossary, while the document’s reference list of Comprehensive Plan verbs defines “Support.”","text":"The document says “support” is not in the Comprehensive Plan glossary.","quote":"Replace support with ensure because support is not in\nthe glossary.","locator":"page 3","verdict":"conflict","evidence":[{"quote":"Support: To aid the cause of.","locator":"page 41","sourceId":"file-a8cc1929-26a"}],"sourceNamed":null}],"summary":[{"id":"s1","text":"This supplemental document collects proposed amendments from CEI Hub community and environmental advocates, presentation slides, and a BPS staff analysis.","citations":[{"quote":"Fr: CEI Hub community and environmental advocates\nRe: Amendments to CEI Hub Policy Project proposal","locator":"page 6","sourceId":"file-a8cc1929-26a"},{"quote":"CEI Hub Policy Project\nCommunity Coalition Amendments to BPS Proposal","locator":"page 42","sourceId":"file-a8cc1929-26a"},{"quote":"BPS Staff Analysis of Community-Proposed Amendments","locator":"page 30","sourceId":"file-a8cc1929-26a"}]},{"id":"s2","text":"The amendments would use one fuel definition and review process, and base fuel reductions on reported storage and consumption data.","citations":[{"quote":"1. Regulate the danger by establishing ONE INCLUSIVE DEFINITION OF “FUEL” applicable throughout Title 33","locator":"page 24","sourceId":"file-a8cc1929-26a"},{"quote":"2. Reduce risk and provide for Oregon’s fuel needs by establishing ONE REVIEW PROTOCOL for all development &\nupgrades.","locator":"page 24","sourceId":"file-a8cc1929-26a"},{"quote":"All fuel reductions through 2036\nmust be based on a comparison between CEI Hub facility\nreported tank data, as defined in Section 17.112.050, and\nState of Oregon reported fuel consumption data.","locator":"page 27","sourceId":"file-a8cc1929-26a"}]},{"id":"s3","text":"The staff analysis says the Comprehensive Plan expresses policy intent, while city codes carry out that intent.","citations":[{"quote":"The Comprehensive Plan is not a regulatory document. It is an expression of policy intent. The zoning code and other city\ncodes are the regulatory tool to implement the policy intent of Comprehensive Plan policies.","locator":"page 30","sourceId":"file-a8cc1929-26a"}]}]},"prompt_version":"file-check-v1","model":"gpt-6-astra","authored_by":"codex_subscription_verified","is_current":true},{"attachment_id":"d300c5e5-a873-4e9b-ae53-1045e030250a","title":"Supplemental Information - Parametrix Model Update","version":1,"status":"published","authored_at":"2026-11-18T06:21:49.465Z","change_kind":"initial","change_note":"1 statement withheld: c6: The unsourced label does not hold because the official record’s impact:economic passage addresses uncertainty about fuel-price effects, citing missing operational data and factors beyond storage capacity.","analysis":{"claims":[{"id":"c1","note":"","text":"The memo projects Oregon liquid fuel demand peaks in 2027 under Current Adopted Policies and 2030 under Delayed Progress.","quote":"Peak demand moves back by one year in the Current\nAdopted Policies and Delayed Progress scenarios to 2027 and 2030, respectively, primarily due to\nthe increase in projected jet fuel demand.","locator":"page 6","verdict":"unsourced","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c2","note":"","text":"The memo estimates 35% spare capacity for annual fuel movement in 2035 under Current Adopted Policies, assuming 12 tank turns per year.","quote":"Table 5: Liquid Fuel Demand (OR Demand + Exports) and Estimated Spare Throughput Capacity at\n12 Tank Turns (1 turn/month)\nCapacity/Utilization Metrics 2024 2030 2035 2040 2050\nCurrent Adopted Policies\nLiquid Fuel Demand + Fuel Export (million gallons) 2,777 2,763 2,394 1,830 977\nEstimated spare throughput capacity % (1\nturn/mo.) 25% 25% 35% 51% 74%","locator":"page 7","verdict":"unsourced","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c3","note":"The memo’s comparison table gives 3,063 million gallons for 2035, while the attached model’s corresponding comparison gives 3,130 million gallons.","text":"The memo’s comparison table projects annual fuel and crude movement of 3,063 million gallons in 2035 under the updated Unchecked Growth scenario.","quote":"Table 3. Model Values – Original vs. 2026 Update Comparison – Unchecked Growth Scenario\nValue 2025 Original Model 2026 Updated Model\n2023 2035 2023 2035\nAnnual throughput – Fuel + Crude (million gallons) 2,653 2,872 3,190 3,063*","locator":"page 4","verdict":"conflict","evidence":[{"quote":"Value\n2023 2035 2023 2035\nAnnual throughput – Fuel + Crude (million gallons) 2,653 2,872 3,190 3,130","locator":"page 24","sourceId":"file-d300c5e5-a87"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c4","note":"","text":"The memo says crude oil exports are expected to cease in 2027 under current permit requirements.","quote":"Looking ahead, crude oil exports are expected to cease in 2027 in alignment with their\ncurrent Title V permit stipulations, freeing up approximately 43 million gallons of gross\nstorage capacity for fuels","locator":"page 5","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Zenith’s Title V permit"},{"id":"c5","note":"","text":"The memo says available data cannot reliably establish the maximum amount of fuel the hub can move over any period.","quote":"there is still no robust way to estimate\nmaximum throughput capacity over any timescale with the current data","locator":"page 8","verdict":"unsourced","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c7","note":"","text":"The memo says the Port of Portland’s airport fuel forecast projects demand of 269 million gallons in 2035 and 305 million gallons in 2045.","quote":"The forecast projects 269 million gallons of fuel demand in 2035 and 305\nmillion gallons in 2045.","locator":"page 12","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Port of Portland"},{"id":"c8","note":"","text":"The memo says ECOnorthwest estimated seasonal gasoline and diesel demand peaks at ~9% and ~10% above their respective lows.","quote":"Taking from the ECOnorthwest report, seasonal peaks for\ngasoline and diesel are expected to be ~9% and ~10% above the demand troughs, respectively.","locator":"page 11","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"ECOnorthwest"},{"id":"c9","note":"","text":"The memo says the hub handles the majority of Oregon’s transportation and liquid fuels.","quote":"The CEI Hub handles the majority of Oregon’s transportation and\nliquid fuels and related products","locator":"page 1","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"The CEI Hub, which consists of Oregon's primary liquid fuel storage and distribution facilities, receives 90 percent of the state's liquid fuel supply either via pipeline or marine vessel.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null}],"summary":[{"id":"s1","text":"This memorandum from Parametrix updates liquid fuel forecasts for Portland’s Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub.","citations":[{"quote":"FROM: Parametrix\nSUBJECT: City of Portland Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub Analysis, Updated Fuel\nForecast Findings","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-d300c5e5-a87"}]},{"id":"s2","text":"The memo projects demand peaks in 2027 and 2030 under its Current Adopted Policies and Delayed Progress scenarios, respectively.","citations":[{"quote":"Peak demand moves back by one year in the Current\nAdopted Policies and Delayed Progress scenarios to 2027 and 2030, respectively, primarily due to\nthe increase in projected jet fuel demand.","locator":"page 6","sourceId":"file-d300c5e5-a87"}]},{"id":"s3","text":"It says incomplete operating data leave the hub’s actual capacity uncertain, and its model cannot determine how storage changes would affect fuel prices.","citations":[{"quote":"This update provides an enhanced picture of flow volumes, but lack of detailed flow data and\noperational constraints with respect to transloading capacity prevents a clear and authoritative view\non existing hub capacity.","locator":"page 14","sourceId":"file-d300c5e5-a87"},{"quote":"Pricing impacts emerge from a range of factors, many of which are not included in this\nmodel, and as such, the model cannot make determinations as to how changes in tank\nvolume will impact fuel pricing in the markets served by the CEI hub.","locator":"page 3","sourceId":"file-d300c5e5-a87"}]}]},"prompt_version":"file-check-v1","model":"gpt-6-astra","authored_by":"codex_subscription_verified","is_current":true},{"attachment_id":"3f472f86-8e56-41be-b5b6-cc3898d2f5bb","title":"Supplemental Information - Title 33 Memo","version":1,"status":"published","authored_at":"2026-11-18T06:23:35.408Z","change_kind":"initial","change_note":"1 statement withheld: c4: The supporting passage in Exhibit B, page 13, limits the more-than-90-percent figure to Oregon’s liquid fuel supply, so it does not establish the broader fuel-supply scope stated in the memo and claim.","analysis":{"claims":[{"id":"c1","note":"","text":"The memo says existing storage capacity would meet projected fuel demand under the recommended expansion limits.","quote":"The 2026 Parametrix model results indicate that sufficient\nstorage capacity would remain available to meet projected fuel demand under the\nrecommended limitations on fuel storage capacity expansions","locator":"page 14","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"Based on the available information, the City does not expect the proposed limitations on fuel storage capacity expansion to constrain projected fuel supply or materially affect business competitiveness, affordability, costs of goods, or household income through fuel price increases.","locator":"impact:economic","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c2","note":"","text":"The memo reports that the larger hypothetical sustained fuel-price increase would reduce cumulative Oregon GDP by approximately 0.21 percent, or $10.99 billion, with approximately 4,550 jobs lost.","quote":"cumulative GDP reduction increased to approximately 0.21 percent, or $10.99 billion,\nwith approximately 4,550 jobs lost.","locator":"page 35","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"ECOnorthwest Memo 2: Fuel Price Volatility and Economic Exposure in Oregon"},{"id":"c3","note":"","text":"The memo says a hypothetical sustained 1 percent fuel-price increase over a 15-year period would reduce cumulative Oregon GDP by approximately $1.15 billion and cost approximately 475 jobs.","quote":"To illustrate the potential magnitude of these effects, EcoNW modeled two sustained\nfuel price scenarios over a 15-year period: a 1 percent increase and a 10 percent\nincrease in the fuel price level. Under the 1 percent scenario, EcoNW estimated a\ncumulative reduction in Oregon GDP of approximately 0.022 percent, or $1.15 billion,\nand a loss of approximately 475 jobs.","locator":"page 34","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"ECOnorthwest Memo 2: Fuel Price Volatility and Economic Exposure in Oregon"},{"id":"c5","note":"","text":"The memo says its Delayed Progress scenario projects peak storage utilization of approximately 78 percent in 2030, declining to 74 percent in 2036.","quote":"Under the\n“Delayed Progress” scenario, the CEI Hub is projected to reach its highest utilization rate\nin 2030, at approximately 78 percent. From there, utilization declines to 74 percent in\n2036, the first year in which projected fuel demand falls below 2024 levels and continues\nto decline more substantially through 2050 (Figure 7).","locator":"page 13","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"2026 Parametrix model"},{"id":"c6","note":"","text":"The memo says projected aviation-fuel demand growth between 2024 and 2036 equals approximately 8.6 million gallons of additional storage capacity, assuming approximately 12 tank turns per year.","quote":"Under the ‘Delayed Progress’ scenario, the updated 2026 Parametrix model\nprojects that annual aviation fuel demand will increase by approximately 103 million\ngallons between 2024 and 2036 (Table 2). Using the model’s assumption of\napproximately 12 tank turns per year, this increase in annual demand is equivalent to\napproximately 8.6 million gallons of additional storage capacity.","locator":"page 36","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"2026 Parametrix Fuel Demand Forecast Model"},{"id":"c7","note":"","text":"The memo lists the hub’s total in-service fuel storage capacity as 315 Million gallons.","quote":"Table 3. In-Service Fuel Storage Capacity Estimates at the CEI Hub (in gals)\nTotal 5% of Total\n315 Million 15.7 Million","locator":"page 37","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"The City estimates that these facilities collectively have a storage\ncapacity of 396 million gallons (Table 1), of which 315 million gallons is in-service storage capacity for\nfuel products (Table 2).","locator":"page 15","sourceId":"file-164c5ae2-808"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c8","note":"","text":"The memo says its Current Adopted Policies scenario projects renewable fuel demand rising approximately 44 percent by 2035, while total liquid fuel demand falls 18 percent.","quote":"Under the “Current Adopted Policies” scenario in the 2026 Parametrix model, which\nassumes the state’s CFP goals are met, annual renewable fuel demand is projected to\nincrease by approximately 44 percent by 2035 (Table 8). However, this increase is more\nthan offset by declining fossil fuel demand, resulting in an overall 18 percent reduction\nin total liquid fuel demand by 2035.","locator":"page 16","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"2026 Parametrix Fuel Demand Forecast Model"},{"id":"c9","note":"","text":"The memo says ECOnorthwest found limited information supporting the model’s assumption that storage tanks could be replenished 12 times annually.","quote":"ECOnorthwest\nnoted that the 2025 Parametrix model had limited information to substantiate the 12\ntank-turn assumption, creating uncertainty around this important model input.","locator":"page 30","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"ECOnorthwest"},{"id":"c10","note":"","text":"The memo says NW Natural’s 2025 resource plan identifies no need to expand its Portland liquefied natural gas storage tank.","quote":"Consistent with\nthese findings, the 2025 IRP does not identify a need to expand the Portland LNG tank\nand continues to treat the facility as a contingency resource rather than a facility\nrequiring long-term growth investment.","locator":"page 18","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"NW Natural, 2025 Integrated Resource Plan"}],"summary":[{"id":"s1","text":"This memo from City planners Tom Armstrong and Julia Michel updates the fuel-demand analysis supporting proposed planning and zoning changes at Portland’s Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub.","citations":[{"quote":"From: Tom Armstrong, Supervising Planner\nJulia Michel, Economic Planner","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-3f472f86-8e5"},{"quote":"This memorandum provides updated information supporting the recommended\nComprehensive Plan policy amendments and Title 33 Zoning Code amendments.","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-3f472f86-8e5"}]},{"id":"s2","text":"The memo says existing storage should meet projected fuel demand and describes a recommendation allowing limited aviation-fuel storage expansion.","citations":[{"quote":"The 2026 Parametrix model results indicate that sufficient\nstorage capacity would remain available to meet projected fuel demand under the\nrecommended limitations on fuel storage capacity expansions","locator":"page 14","sourceId":"file-3f472f86-8e5"},{"quote":"To provide additional flexibility, the Planning Commission\nrecommendation is to allow limited expansion of aviation fuel storage capacity, up to 5\npercent of each terminal’s in-service fuel storage capacity.","locator":"page 36","sourceId":"file-3f472f86-8e5"}]},{"id":"s3","text":"It also summarizes hypothetical fuel-price impacts, while stressing that the analysis does not predict whether the proposed regulations would raise prices.","citations":[{"quote":"Note that\nthe analysis does not predict whether, or to what extent, the City’s proposed regulations\nwould affect fuel prices. Instead, the scenarios illustrate the potential economic\nimplications if fuel prices were to increase.","locator":"page 34","sourceId":"file-3f472f86-8e5"}]}]},"prompt_version":"file-check-v1","model":"gpt-6-astra","authored_by":"codex_subscription_verified","is_current":true},{"attachment_id":"86ab0504-86d5-468d-b4bd-97663763ac5e","title":"Supplemental Information – ECONW Memo 1 Model Review","version":1,"status":"published","authored_at":"2026-11-18T07:29:17.243Z","change_kind":"initial","change_note":"Every sentence and label passed the quotation checks and the independent review.","analysis":{"claims":[{"id":"c1","note":"","text":"The memo describes a draft policy requiring each bulk fuel terminal to reduce fuel storage capacity by 20 percent by 2036.","quote":"The City is evaluating a\nproposed draft policy that would, among other changes, amend City code to require a 20\npercent fuel storage capacity reduction (“drawdown”) at each bulk fuel terminal by 2036.","locator":"page 1","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"Other city code amendments will require a 20 percent fuel storage capacity reduction (“drawdown”) by\n2036 at each bulk fuel terminal in the CEI Hub","locator":"page 12","sourceId":"file-164c5ae2-808"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c2","note":"","text":"The memo says modeled demand uses approximately 70 percent of achievable annual fuel throughput in 2023, falling to 56 percent by 2035 under the current adopted policies scenario.","quote":"the Parametrix model indicates\nthat under baseline assumptions, demand is well within the Hub’s throughput capacity over\nthe analysis period, at approximately 70 percent of achievable annual throughput in 2023,\ndeclining to 56 percent by 2035 under the current adopted policies scenario.","locator":"page 1","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Parametrix model"},{"id":"c3","note":"","text":"The memo says the proposed policies’ effects on fuel prices remain uncertain.","quote":"However, there remains uncertainty about what, if any, impact either of the\nproposed policies might have on fuel prices.","locator":"page 2","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"There are other factors that impact fuel prices and there remains uncertainty, especially due to the lack of available data, about what, if any, impact the regulations may have on fuel prices.","locator":"impact:economic","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c4","note":"","text":"The memo quotes Parametrix as forecasting that Oregon’s combined fossil and renewable fuel demand will peak in all scenarios by 2029 or before.","quote":"They find that, “Despite population growth and increased renewable fuel usage,\nOregon fuel demand volumes (fossil fuel plus renewable fuels) are expected to peak in all\nscenarios by 2029 or before” (Parametrix 2025, 1).","locator":"page 3","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Parametrix 2025"},{"id":"c5","note":"","text":"The memo quotes Parametrix as saying that turning over tank contents every 21 days increases annual throughput capacity by 45 percent compared with the one-month baseline.","quote":"Parametrix notes, “[t]he results of the modeling tool are highly sensitive to tank turns/dwell\ntime. If one turn can be achieved every three weeks (21 days), that represents a 45 percent\nincrease in annual throughput capacity compared to the one-month base.","locator":"page 5","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Parametrix"},{"id":"c6","note":"","text":"The memo says hub gasoline tanks averaged 40 percent full between 2020 and 2024 but reached 80 percent full on the peak day across those years.","quote":"For\ninstance, gasoline tanks at the CEI Hub were only 40 percent full on an average day between\n2020 and 2024, however were up to 80 percent full on the peak day across these years.5","locator":"page 6","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Parametrix model"},{"id":"c7","note":"","text":"The memo says Parametrix lacked confidential data on fuel import and export rates and estimated them using tank capacity and historical fuel demand.","quote":"Parametrix did not have access to (confidential) import or export rate data and thus\ngenerated estimates for these factors using inferences from tank storage capacity, and\nhistoric fuel demand.1","locator":"page 4","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Parametrix 2025"},{"id":"c8","note":"","text":"The memo says the model combines storage volumes rather than modeling individual tanks or terminals separately.","quote":"3 “Though tanks have been categorized by the primary type of compound they store (fuels,\nfuel additives, crude oil, etc.), storage volumes are modeled in aggregate (individual tanks/terminals\nare not modeled separately).” (Parametrix 2025, 5)","locator":"page 6","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Parametrix 2025"},{"id":"c9","note":"","text":"The memo says Parametrix uses average annual fuel demand and does not capture seasonal changes within a year.","quote":"The Parametrix demand analysis uses average annual fuel demand and does not capture the\nimpact of seasonality within a year.4","locator":"page 6","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Parametrix 2025"},{"id":"c10","note":"","text":"The memo says its baseline of one tank turnover per month was calibrated using federal data showing an average fuel supply time of approximately 25 days.","quote":"The model’s baseline of one tank turn per month is calibrated from U.S. Energy Information\nAdministration data reflecting an average fuel supply time of approximately 25 days,\nsuggesting the baseline throughput assumption is achievable under normal operating\nconditions.","locator":"page 5","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"U.S. Energy Information Administration"}],"summary":[{"id":"s1","text":"This memo from ECOnorthwest reviews a fuel-demand model and possible economic effects of Portland’s proposed fuel-storage regulations.","citations":[{"quote":"FROM: ECOnorthwest\nSUBJECT: Memo 1: Parametrix Model Review and Policy Implications","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-86ab0504-86d"},{"quote":"Bureau of Planning and Sustainability (BPS) asked ECOnorthwest (ECO) to independently\nreview the fuel demand model designed by Parametrix and to provide an additional\neconomic assessment to specifically address how the City’s proposed regulations could\naffect Oregon’s economy.","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-86ab0504-86d"}]},{"id":"s2","text":"The memo says the model suggests spare capacity at the fuel hub, provided its key assumptions hold.","citations":[{"quote":"These results\nsuggest spare capacity (if the model’s key assumptions hold).","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-86ab0504-86d"}]},{"id":"s3","text":"It says spare capacity alone cannot establish whether the proposed policies would affect fuel prices.","citations":[{"quote":"A determination of excess capacity alone isn’t a\nsufficient condition to understand if there are price (or other) impacts related to the\nproposed policy changes, and this is the primary limitation to the Parametrix study, and its\nuse for conducting a comprehensive policy analysis.","locator":"page 2","sourceId":"file-86ab0504-86d"}]}]},"prompt_version":"file-check-v1","model":"gpt-6-astra","authored_by":"codex_subscription_verified","is_current":true},{"attachment_id":"5ee9f4bf-5992-47a1-819b-012928182876","title":"Supplemental Information – ECONW Memo 2 Fuel Price Volatility","version":1,"status":"published","authored_at":"2026-11-18T07:27:47.607Z","change_kind":"initial","change_note":"1 statement withheld: c4: The unsourced label fails because Exhibit B—original, page 13, and the official record’s impact:purpose passage address the statement, reporting that more than 90 percent of Oregon’s liquid fuel supply passes through the CEI Hub.","analysis":{"claims":[{"id":"c1","note":"","text":"The memo estimates that hypothetical fuel price increases could reduce Oregon’s cumulative GDP by $1.15 billion to $10.99 billion over the fifteen-year analysis period.","quote":"All else equal,\nOregon's cumulative GDP could decrease by between $1.15 billion and $10.99 billion over\nthe fifteen-year analysis period.","locator":"page 2","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"(REMI 2026) and Analysis by ECOnorthwest"},{"id":"c2","note":"","text":"The memo estimates average annual employment losses of 475 jobs under its 1 percent scenario and 4,550 jobs under its sustained 10 percent scenario.","quote":"When evaluating the impact of price increases on jobs, the lower bound scenario of a 1\npercent increase annually over the 15-year time horizon would result in an average annual\nemployment decrease of 475 jobs, the upper bound of a 10 percent sustained increased\nwould result in an average annual employment decrease of 4,550 jobs.","locator":"page 22","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"(REMI 2026) and Analysis by ECOnorthwest"},{"id":"c3","note":"The executive summary describes the lower bound as a sustained 1 percent increase, while the later discussion describes it as a one-year 1 percent shock.","text":"The memo’s executive summary says its lower bound uses a sustained 1 percent fuel price increase.","quote":"A lower bound scenario was created that reflects a sustained 1 percent price shock, and an\nupper bound reflects a sustained 10 percent increase in the fuel price level.","locator":"page 2","verdict":"conflict","evidence":[{"quote":"The lower bound reflects the one-year 1 percent price shock, and the upper bound\nreflects a sustained 10 percent increase in the fuel price level.","locator":"page 22","sourceId":"file-5ee9f4bf-599"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c5","note":"","text":"The memo says the proposed regulatory program would require bulk fuel terminals at the hub to reduce storage tank capacity by 2036.","quote":"The year 2036 was selected to model the possible price impacts that might result\nfrom the proposed regulatory program that would require the CEI Hub bulk fuel terminals to\nreduce their storage tank capacity by 2036.","locator":"page 9","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"Other city code amendments will require a 20 percent fuel storage capacity reduction (“drawdown”) by\n2036 at each bulk fuel terminal in the CEI Hub and clarify that a building permit is required for structural\nsupport for “piping carrying combustible, flammable or hazardous materials”.","locator":"page 12","sourceId":"file-164c5ae2-808"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c6","note":"","text":"The memo says Oregon ranked fourth nationally for regular gasoline prices, averaging $5.10 per gallon as of April 28, 2026.","quote":"Using regular gasoline as a proxy for broader fuel price conditions, Oregon ranks as the fourth\nmost expensive state in the country, with an average price of $5.10 per gallon as of April 28,\n2026, compared to a national average of $4.18 per gallon","locator":"page 21","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"AAA 2026"},{"id":"c7","note":"","text":"The memo says the bottom 60 percent of income earners spend close to 4 percent of take-home pay on gasoline, compared with roughly 2 percent for the highest earners.","quote":"The bottom 60 percent\nof income earners devote close to 4 percent of their take-home pay to gasoline, compared to\nroughly 2 percent for the highest earners, meaning fuel price increases are regressive in\nnature and fall hardest on those least able to absorb the cost (RBC Economics 2026).","locator":"page 7","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"RBC Economics 2026"},{"id":"c8","note":"","text":"The memo says a 5 percent increase in oil prices adds approximately 0.1 percent to the inflation rate.","quote":"As a rough rule\nof thumb, a 5 percent increase in oil prices adds approximately 0.1 percent to the inflation\nrate (Lynch 2026).","locator":"page 6","verdict":"cited","evidence":[],"sourceNamed":"Lynch 2026"}],"summary":[{"id":"s1","text":"This memo from ECOnorthwest examines how hypothetical fuel price increases could affect Oregon’s economy.","citations":[{"quote":"FROM: ECOnorthwest\nSUBJECT: Memo 2: Fuel Price Volatility and Economic Exposure in Oregon","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-5ee9f4bf-599"},{"quote":"To estimate what higher fuel costs could mean for Oregon, ECOnorthwest used REMI PI+, a\ndynamic regional economic modeling platform, to simulate the economic effects of\nhypothetical fuel cost increases ranging from modest to severe.","locator":"page 2","sourceId":"file-5ee9f4bf-599"}]},{"id":"s2","text":"The memo estimates cumulative losses of $1.15 billion to $10.99 billion in Oregon’s economic production over a fifteen-year analysis period.","citations":[{"quote":"All else equal,\nOregon's cumulative GDP could decrease by between $1.15 billion and $10.99 billion over\nthe fifteen-year analysis period.","locator":"page 2","sourceId":"file-5ee9f4bf-599"}]},{"id":"s3","text":"It says lasting increases cause greater economic losses than temporary shocks, but does not predict a particular policy’s effect on fuel prices.","citations":[{"quote":"Those consequences scale with both the magnitude and the duration of the price\nchange, with sustained increases producing substantially larger and more persistent\neconomic losses than temporary shocks of equivalent size.","locator":"page 2","sourceId":"file-5ee9f4bf-599"},{"quote":"The\nanalysis presented here does not assert that any particular policy will cause any specific price\noutcome.","locator":"page 24","sourceId":"file-5ee9f4bf-599"}]}]},"prompt_version":"file-check-v1","model":"gpt-6-astra","authored_by":"codex_subscription_verified","is_current":true},{"attachment_id":"e4149492-bd74-4ab1-8f45-bee01f8a3853","title":"Withdrawn amendment – Green/Pirtle-Guiney/Kanal/Clark/Koyama Lane 1","version":1,"status":"published","authored_at":"2026-11-17T16:23:58.641Z","change_kind":"initial","change_note":"1 statement withheld: c1: The page 1 reference to Figure 3.10 does not establish a named outside source absent from the packet; the record’s description identifies Figure 3-10 as the project’s CEI Hub policy-geography map.","analysis":{"claims":[{"id":"c2","note":"","text":"The amendment says the Hub sits on soils that can lose strength during earthquakes, in an area exposed to natural hazards that pose significant risks.","quote":"The CEI Hub is located on liquefiable soils in an area subject to natural hazards,\nposing significant risk in the event of an accident or earthquake.","locator":"page 1","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"Numerous studies have found that the concentration of bulk fuel terminals in the CEI Hub presents\nsignificant risks, primarily due to the CEI Hub’s location on land with a high risk of liquefaction. In the\nevent of a major earthquake, particularly a Cascadia Subduction Zone (CSZ) event, storage tanks in the\nCEI Hub are likely to fail, releasing fuel and other hazardous materials.","locator":"page 15","sourceId":"file-164c5ae2-808"}],"sourceNamed":null},{"id":"c3","note":"","text":"The amendment says BPS proposed three review systems for bulk fuel terminals.","quote":"Description: Establishes two review criteria systems, replacing the three review systems\nproposed by BPS:","locator":"page 4","verdict":"supported","evidence":[{"quote":"The zoning code amendments also create three Bulk Fuel Terminal Reviews under which approval may be granted for: expansion of existing or creation of new transloading facilities; a limited increase in aviation fuel storage capacity; and the transfer of storage tank capacity from one terminal to another.","locator":"description","sourceId":"record"}],"sourceNamed":null}],"summary":[{"id":"s1","text":"The withdrawn amendment from Green, Pirtle-Guiney, Kanal, Clark and Koyama Lane would add language about the Critical Energy Infrastructure Hub to Portland’s Comprehensive Plan.","citations":[{"quote":"Amendment – Green/Pirtle-Guiney/Kanal/Clark/Koyama Lane 1\nAmendment #1 (CEI Hub Introductory Language for Comprehensive Plan)\nDescription: Adds language to the beginning of the Rivers Pattern Area section of the\nComprehensive Plan framing the CEI Hub.","locator":"page 1","sourceId":"file-e4149492-bd7"}]},{"id":"s2","text":"It would establish separate reviews for replacing fuel storage tanks and expanding storage capacity, with safety requirements and limits on expansion.","citations":[{"quote":"• Fuel Storage Tank Replacement Review – Allows existing bulk fuel terminals to replace\naging storage tanks in order to improve safety and seismic resilience. Approval is\nconditioned on building the new tank to high seismic standards, maintaining compliance\nwith state risk mitigation requirements, not increasing site risk, and removing at least an\nequivalent amount of old tank capacity.","locator":"page 4","sourceId":"file-e4149492-bd7"},{"quote":"• Fuel Storage Tank Capacity Expansion Review – Allows limited expansion or\nreconfiguration of fuel storage capacity at existing terminals only when there is a\ndemonstrated need and clear public benefit.","locator":"page 4","sourceId":"file-e4149492-bd7"}]},{"id":"s3","text":"The amendment would also broaden neighborhood notification and encourage identifying alternative locations for the fuel facilities.","citations":[{"quote":"Description: Adds additional neighborhoods impacted by activity at the Hub to subsection (B),\nadds (C) as a form of public notification, adds (D) as a technical header to contextualize (D)1-4,\nand clarifies the instances when notifications specified in (B) and (C) are triggered.","locator":"page 3","sourceId":"file-e4149492-bd7"},{"quote":"support efforts to identify alternative locations for these\nfacilities in recognition of the ongoing economic risk of concentrating bulk fuel facilities in a\nnatural hazard risk area.","locator":"page 2","sourceId":"file-e4149492-bd7"}]}]},"prompt_version":"file-check-v1","model":"gpt-6-astra","authored_by":"codex_subscription_verified","is_current":true}],"notice":"Automated summaries and source checks by Portland Civic Lab. No person reviewed them before publication. Labels compare a file with the rest of the official record and do not judge whether a statement is true. Replaced and withdrawn versions are retained."}