Direct the City Attorney’s Office to seek required approvals related to the Settlement Agreement with the United States Department of Justice and comply with any…
The purpose of the Resolution is to direct the City Attorney’s Office to seek required approvals for amendments to Portland City Code, to implement an oversight system to investigate and make disciplinary decisions for Portland Police Bureau sworn employees and supervisors thereof. This Resolution also directs the City Attorney’s Office to comply with any mandatory collective bargaining obligations that relate to these amendments of the City Code. The potential amendments would allow Council to define more clearly the bias(es) that may serve as cause not to nominate an applicant for Board membership, or cause to remove a seated Board member. It also would allow Council…
The current and former Councils received substantial community input through this process, including through the Police Accountability Commission process, which yielded 1500+ Portlanders' input, town halls during the 2023-2024 Council's review and changes to the proposed Code totaling ~50 Portlanders in attendance, and subsequently several comments to the new Council asking for changes, primarily to define "bias."The change would allow for additional community representation on the nominating committee, and allow for community members to have more certainty about their eligibility for service on the new Community Board for Police Accountability.
This legislation does not require changes to current FTE or budgets and does not result in new financial obligations.Under Charter 2-10, funding for the Oversight System shall be proportional to be no less than 5 percent of the Police Bureau’s Annual Operational Budget.
An Economic and Real Estate Development Impact Analysis was not submitted for this proposed action. Pursuant to City Council Resolution 37664, Prosper Portland staff has reviewed the action and agree that it does not require an Economic and Real Estate Development Impact Analysis.
2 files of 3 posted to this record have a plain summary. 2 factual statements were compared with the rest of the record. None differs from another official passage. 1 matches another document. 1 cites an outside source.
The amended exhibit proposes rules for Portland’s community police oversight system, including investigations of officer misconduct and discipline. It would bar board applicants unable to decide cases impartially and require the nominating committee to consider whether applicants’ prior statements about law enforcement show that inability. It also provides for community members from each Council district on the board’s nominating committee.
1 matches the record
Read the 1 statement checked
Matches the record
The exhibit says Title 35 was added by Ordinance 191892, effective October 11, 2024.
The file says
Title 35 Community Police Oversight
Board
(Title added by Ordinance 191892, effective October 11, 2024)
The exhibit presents proposed code for Portland’s Community Board for Police Accountability, including rules for selecting board members. The exhibit would define disqualifying bias as an inability to decide matters impartially and would apply that standard to removing board members.
1 cites an outside source
Read the 1 statement checked
Cites an outside source
The exhibit says Ordinance 191892 added the police oversight code title, effective October 11, 2024.
The file says
(Title added by Ordinance 191892, effective October 11, 2024)
Source named in the file: Ordinance 191892. This site has not checked it.
Compared with the record page and the City's analyses.
How to read these labels
Matches the record
Another official document on this record says the same thing. That shows the documents agree. It does not show the statement is true, and the two documents may come from the same office.
Conflicts with the record
Another official passage on this record says something different. Both passages are shown. This site does not decide which one is right.
Differs from its cited source
The document attributes the statement to a source on this record, and that source reads differently. Both passages are shown.
Cites an outside source
The document names a source that is not part of this record. This site has not checked that source.
No source given
The document does not say where the statement comes from, and the record documents this check read do not address it. This does not mean the statement is wrong.
Summaries and labels are written by software and checked by a second automated pass. No person reviewed them before publication. Each label rests on the quoted passages shown with it, and compares a file only with the other official documents on this record. Written testimony from residents is not checked. Every version, including replaced and withdrawn ones, stays public.
Official title: Direct the City Attorney’s Office to seek required approvals related to the Settlement Agreement with the United States Department of Justice and comply with any mandatory collective bargaining obligations for amendments to City Code related to the Community Police Oversight Board
First seen is when this site’s hourly check found a file. The City may have posted it up to an hour earlier. Read the full official text
WHEREAS, on July 30th, 2020 the Portland City Council voted to refer a Charter Amendment to the voters of Portland authorizing the creation of a police oversight system to promptly, fairly, and impartially investigate and impose discipline on Portland Police Bureau sworn employees and supervisors thereof and to make recommendations regarding police directives with a primary focus on community concerns; andWHEREAS, on November 3rd, 2020 Portland voters approved the Charter Amendment supporting the measure by 81.58%; andWHEREAS, on July 28, 2021, Council unanimously adopted Resolution No. 37548, creating the Police Accountability Commission (PAC) to develop recommendations and suggested code provisions for the new oversight system; andWHEREAS, the PAC members, supported by dedicated staff in the Community Safety Division, worked diligently and tirelessly at their assigned task from December 2021 through August 2023; andWHEREAS, on April 29, 2022, the United States District Court in the United States v. City of Portland, Oregon, entered amendments to the settlement agreement (Settlement Agreement) between the United States Department of Justice (DOJ) and the City of Portland (City), including paragraph 195 which requires the City to implement the Charter Amendments establishing a community police oversight board; andWHEREAS, on September 21, 2023, the PAC presented to Council its 504-page report (440 pages of which were appendices documenting their work) and a recommended 96-page City Code package to create the Community Board for Police Accountability and Office of Community-led Police Accountability; and after hearing the report presentation, discussing the recommendations with PAC members, and taking community testimony, the Council unanimously voted to accept the report; andWHEREAS, the Settlement Agreement requires Council to seek approval from the DOJ of proposed amendments to the City Code to implement the Charter Amendments, and to comply with any corresponding bargaining obligation that may exist; andWHEREAS, on November 15, 2023, the City Council adopted Resolution 37637, which directed the City Attorney to seek approvals of Settlement Agreement and City Code amendments from the US Department of Justice and, as applicable the Federal Court, and comply with collective bargaining obligations; andWHEREAS, on August 29, 2024, the Federal Court held a fairness hearing to consider amendments to the Settlement Agreement to incorporate the Oversight System and at the conclusion of the hearing the Court adopted the amendments; andWHEREAS, on October 11, 2024, the City Council adopted Ordinance 191892, creating Code Title 35; andWHEREAS, the previous City Council’s authorization of Code included significant deviations from the recommendations of the Police Accountability Commission, and members of the public felt the Code was not consistent with the vision of the Charter amendments in 2020 and the will of the voters; andWHEREAS, it is vital to ensure that prospective Board members are able to hear and make decisions on the matters before the CBPA without bias; andWHEREAS, a clear and consistent definition of "bias" is necessary to ensure this impartiality, and the effectiveness of the new community police oversight board; andWHEREAS, the recommended City Code amendments, attached as Exhibit A, will implement the will of the voters as reflected in the Charter Amendments to establish a community police oversight board, and create a fair and impartial community-led oversight system where imposed discipline can be upheld;NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, Council directs the City Attorney’s Office, after consideration with Council staff of community feedback, to seek required approvals from the United States Department of Justice for amendments to the City Code in a form substantially similar to Exhibit A, andBE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, the City Attorney’s Office and Bureau of Human Resources, after consideration with Council staff of community feedback, are hereby authorized to comply with any collective bargaining obligations the City may have and to reach agreement on the terms of the proposed City Code amendments in a form substantially similar to Exhibit A; andBE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, upon completion of its engagement with the DOJ and any mandatory collective bargaining obligations, the City Attorney’s Office shall return to Council for adoption of the City Code amendments approved by DOJ.
Meeting history1 meeting · 0 votes
Continued as amendedAgenda item 2
Motion to amend Exhibit A to replace Code Subsection 35.20.010 F.3. with the following: “Any individual who displays a state of mind that indicates the individual could not reach decisions as a member of the CBPA impartially, without prejudice, and without a basis in bias. In order to determine whether the individual has such a state of mind, the nominating committee will consider, among other factors, whether an individual’s prior statements regarding law enforcement demonstrate an inability to be impartial.”: Moved by Novick and seconded by Kanal. (Aye (3) Kanal, Morillo, Novick; Nay (2) Smith, Zimmerman)
Read all 1 exact motions
Feb 25, 2025 · Amendment · Recorded
Motion to amend Exhibit A to replace Code Subsection 35.20.010 F.3. with the following: “Any individual who displays a state of mind that indicates the individual could not reach decisions as a member of the CBPA impartially, without prejudice, and without a basis in bias. In order to determine whether the individual has such a state of mind, the nominating committee will consider, among other factors, whether an individual’s prior statements regarding law enforcement demonstrate an inability to be impartial.”: Moved by Novick and seconded by Kanal. (Aye (3) Kanal, Morillo, Novick; Nay (2) Smith, Zimmerman)
About this recordSource checks & change history
0 human-reviewed findings are linked to this record. Unreviewed machine-extracted fragments are not presented as findings.
Technical information-completeness check · Ready With Caveats · Rules v2
This checks whether decision-relevant categories appear in the published packet. It does not recommend approval or opposition.
Decision definition
The official title and operative text identify the requested action.
Complete
Official legal text
Official text was found. This check does not certify that every referenced exhibit is complete.
Complete
Financial impact
The official impact statement includes financial information.
Complete
Funding source
The impact statement identifies funding information without an explicit unresolved-source qualifier.
Complete
Supporting documents
3 linked supporting documents found; presence alone does not verify their internal completeness.
Complete
Referenced exhibit integrity
The text references exhibits. This guide has not yet automatically verified that each referenced exhibit is present, populated, and internally consistent.
Unknown
Counterparty acceptance
The reviewed action is not expressly identified as a non-binding agreement.
Not Applicable
Implementation
A direction, reporting requirement, or deadline appears in the official text.
Complete
Document stability
Stability requires at least two observed snapshots; the system will update this after another ingestion.