Resolution2026-069

Appoint members to the Community Board for Police Accountability

The path so far

Each stop is a meeting in the official record, with the City’s own words for what happened.

  1. RescheduledMeeting guide
  2. Adopted as amendedMeeting guide
  3. Where it standsFinal Council action complete
  4. After the decisionFollow-through is not tracked yetA final vote is not the same as the work being done.

In brief

From the official impact statement

This legislation appoints three alternates to full membership on the Community Board for Police Accountability (CBPA), to fill three vacancies. It also requests that administrative staff supporting the CBPA begin the process of re-evaluating previous applicants to provide Council with options to appoint previous applicants as alternates. The CBPA has 21 member and 6 alternate positions; following this legislation, all 21 members and 1/6 alternates will be filled.This legislation also adjusts the term lengths of remaining members to align with the meeting dates of the CBPA, which will hold its first meeting on February 11, 2026.This body was established per Ballot Measure…

Official impact statement

Decision details

From the official record
Who is affected

During the application process, the Administrative and Onboarding Coordinator for the Office of Community-Based Accountability sent over 250 emails that advertised the volunteer opportunity to the following community partners: 1000 Friends of OregonACLUAll Hands RaisedAlliance for a Healthier GenerationAPANOBasic Rights OregonBlack Parent InitiativeBlack Reliance FundBlack United FundBuilding Power for Communities of ColorBusiness for Better PortlandCAIR OregonCAIROCoalition of Communities of ColorCommunity Investment TrustCultivate InitiativesDisability Rights OregonDivision Midway AllianceDress for SuccessEast Portland Action PlanEducate YaFriendly House Inc.Health Justice Recovery AllianceHispanic Chamber of CommerceKarios PDXLatino NetworkLeague of Women VotersLewis and Clark – Gender StudiesLewis and Clark – Health StudiesLewis and Clark – Latin America and Latino StudiesLewis and Clark – Political ScienceLewis and Clark – SociologyMercy CorpsMultnomah County Public Health Advisory BoardMultnomah County ReachNAACPNeighborhood Associations - AllOur Just FutureOregon Justice Resource CenterOregon WalksPartners of DiversityPolice Accountability Commission (PAC) - former membersPortland Chamber of CommercePortland Community College – Alcohol and Addiction CounselingPortland Community College – CommunicationsPortland Community College – Criminal JusticePortland Community College – ParalegalPortland Community College – Political SciencePortland Metro ChamberPortland Public School Principals – AllPortland Public School Parent Teach Organizations – mostPortland Community College- Race, Indigenous, Nations, and GenderPortland State University – College of Urban and PUblic AffairsPortland State University – School of Social WorkProsper PortlandQ CenterReed College – Political ScienceReed College – SociologyReimagine OregonRosewood InitiativeSafety and Justice OregonStreet TrustUnited Way of the Columbia-WillametteUrban LeagueVenture Portland And attended the following public meetings to share the volunteer opportunity: Citizen Review Committee meeting - March 5, 2025PCCEP meeting - March 26, 2025Citizen Review Committee meeting - April 2, 2025East Columbia Neighborhood Association meeting - April 8, 2025Irvington Neighborhood Association Meeting - April 9, 2025Social Media Outreach: Rose City Connection - sent to 4,000 recipients on March 11, March 18, March 25, April 1, April 8.City Insider Employee Newsletter - sent to more than 6,800 recipients on March 11, April 1, April 8.Our City in the News internal news roundup - sent to more than 850 subscribers on March 5.CivicLife newsletter – includes 4,144 subscribers.Posted to many City Councilor's newsletters and social media posts.The City’s social media websites – posted twice. Statistics from initial posting below. Second posting beginning April 4, with boosts on platforms through April 11Instagram:First postPost interactions: 94 likesLikes: 41Saves: 16Comments: 2Second postPost interactions: 115Likes: 57Shares: 41Saves:17Comments: 0Facebook:First postViews: 369Interactions: 21 share1 commentSecond postViews: 474Interactions: 1Link Clicks: 1X:First PostViews: 343Interactions: 52 reposts2 likes1 commentSecond postViews: 420Likes: 3Shares: 1Comments: 3Next Door:Impressions: 2,133LinkedIn:Impressions: 3,581Total Engagement: 63Likes: 46Reposts: 15Comments: 2The community impacts of this legislation are largely the same as the impacts of the initial appointments and the report from February 3, 2026 regarding resignations and removals; moving three alternates to membership status will not fundamentally change the impact of the CBPA's membership and structure.

Official community impact statement
Financial impact

This resolution does not change CBPA appropriations. The $500 stipend for each member of the CBPA will continue to be issued to the updated membership, and the $500 stipend for the alternate members' stipends will remain budgeted for future alternate appointments. The total cost of $13,500 will come out of the oversight system's budget, which is required to be equal to 5% of PPB's operating budget and which was budgeted in the FY 2026-2027 fiscal year.

Official financial impact statement
Prosper Portland analysis

An Economic and Real Estate Development Impact Analysis was not submitted for this proposed action. Pursuant to City Council Resolution 37664, Prosper Portland staff has reviewed the action and agree that it does not require an Economic and Real Estate Development Impact Analysis.

Economic and real estate development analysis, provided by Prosper Portland

Recorded action

What the posted files say

Automated check by Civic Lab

2 files of 2 posted to this record have a plain summary. 7 factual statements were compared with the rest of the record. 1 differs from another official passage. 3 match another document. 3 cite an outside source.

Ballot Measure 26-217,

Checked Nov 18, 2026

This exhibit presents proposed Charter changes and ballot language authorizing an independent board to investigate police complaints and impose discipline. The ballot summary says City Council would approve board appointments and funding would be no less than 5% of the Police Bureau’s annual operational budget.

  • 1 matches the record
  • 1 conflicts with the record
Read the 2 statements checked
  1. Conflicts with the record

    The ballot summary says immediate family members of both current and former law enforcement employees may not serve on the board.

    The file says
    Current, former employees of law enforcement agencies and their immediate family members may not serve on the Board.
    page 3 · Ballot Measure 26-217,
    The record says
    People currently employed by a law enforcement agency and their immediate family members are not eligible for service on the Board. People who were formerly employed by a law enforcement agency are not eligible for service on the Board.
    page 1 · Ballot Measure 26-217,

    The ballot summary excludes immediate family members of current and former employees; the proposed Charter text excludes immediate family members only of current employees.

  2. Matches the record

    The ballot summary says the board would investigate police complaints and impose discipline.

    The file says
    The measure adds a new Charter section authorizing an independent body to: investigate complaints against police employees; investigate all deaths in custody, uses of deadly force, complaints of force that result in injury, discrimination against protected classes, violations of constitutional rights; impose discipline deemed appropriate by the Board;
    page 3 · Ballot Measure 26-217,
    The record says
    a new Community Police Oversight Board to replace IPR for investigations of certain complaints of police misconduct and to replace the Chief of Police for imposition of discipline.
    sponsor's impact statement · Official record
Compared with the record page and the City's analyses, (195). Part of the record was too long to compare.

(195)

Checked Nov 18, 2026

The document is an amended settlement agreement between the United States and the City of Portland. The agreement requires changes to police policies, training and practices covering force, mental health services, crisis intervention, employee monitoring, accountability and community engagement. The agreement assigns misconduct investigations to oversight staff and disciplinary decisions to the Community Board for Police Accountability for cases within its jurisdiction.

Only 71 of 73 pages had readable text. Scanned pages were not checked.

  • 2 matches the record
  • 3 cites an outside source
Read the 5 statements checked
  1. Matches the record

    The agreement says voters approved a 2020 measure creating a community police oversight board to replace Independent Police Review for certain misconduct investigations and the police chief for discipline.

    The file says
    In 2020, the City referred to voters a ballot measure that would overhaul the police accountability system incorporated into this Agreement by establishing a new Community Police Oversight Board to replace IPR for investigations of certain complaints of police misconduct and to replace the Chief of Police for imposition of discipline. City voters approved the ballot measure.
    page 40 · (195)
    The record says
    WHEREAS, in November 2020 Portland voters approved a ballot measure, with 81.58% in favor, creating a new police accountability and oversight system, adding it to the Charter as Chapter 2-10;
    record text · Official record
    The record says
    In order for the City to be in compliance with the Department of Justice (DOJ)'s settlement agreement, the City must establish "a new Community Police Oversight Board to replace IPR for investigations of certain complaints of police misconduct and to replace the Chief of Police for imposition of discipline." (195)
    sponsor's impact statement · Official record
  2. Cites an outside source

    The agreement says the United States found failures involving force, training, officer accountability and community engagement, while the City did not admit the allegations.

    The file says
    Specifically, the United States found that the City failed to implement the following provisions of this Agreement: Section III – Use of Force, Paragraphs 66, 67, 69, 70, and 73; Section IV – Training, Paragraphs 78 and 84; Section VIII – Officer Accountability, Paragraphs 121, 123, and 169; and Section IX – Community Engagement and Creation of Portland Committee on Community Engaged Policing, Paragraph 150. The City does not admit that the allegations of noncompliance are true.
    page 37 · (195)

    Source named in the file: United States. This site has not checked it.

  3. Matches the record

    The agreement says the City empowered a civilian commission to submit a police oversight proposal to City Council for final approval.

    The file says
    The City has since empowered a 20-member civilian Commission to define the duties and authority of the Oversight Board and submit a proposal to City Council for final approval.
    page 40 · (195)
    The record says
    The Police Accountability Commission (PAC), appointed by City Council, spent two years gathering information from community members and made recommendations to the former City Council.
    sponsor's impact statement · Official record
  4. Cites an outside source

    The agreement says the United States issued a notice of noncompliance on April 2, 2021.

    The file says
    On April 2, 2021, the United States issued a notice of noncompliance pursuant to Paragraph 178.
    page 37 · (195)

    Source named in the file: notice of noncompliance. This site has not checked it.

  5. Cites an outside source

    The agreement says the Portland Police Bureau already has an Employee Information System to identify employees needing assistance and develop strategies addressing their issues.

    The file says
    PPB has an existing Employee Information System (“EIS”) to identify employees and design assistance strategies to address specific issues affecting the employee. See PPB Manual 345.00.
    page 28 · (195)

    Source named in the file: PPB Manual 345.00. This site has not checked it.

Compared with the record page and the City's analyses, Ballot Measure 26-217,.
How to read these labels
Matches the record
Another official document on this record says the same thing. That shows the documents agree. It does not show the statement is true, and the two documents may come from the same office.
Conflicts with the record
Another official passage on this record says something different. Both passages are shown. This site does not decide which one is right.
Differs from its cited source
The document attributes the statement to a source on this record, and that source reads differently. Both passages are shown.
Cites an outside source
The document names a source that is not part of this record. This site has not checked that source.
No source given
The document does not say where the statement comes from, and the record documents this check read do not address it. This does not mean the statement is wrong.

Summaries and labels are written by software and checked by a second automated pass. No person reviewed them before publication. Each label rests on the quoted passages shown with it, and compares a file only with the other official documents on this record. Written testimony from residents is not checked. Every version, including replaced and withdrawn ones, stays public.

See an error? Report it to Portland Civic Lab. A check found to be wrong is withdrawn with a dated public note.

Sources & history

Documents3

Official title: Appoint members to the Community Board for Police Accountability

Resolution 37737Final official action · Portland.govFirst seen is when this site’s hourly check found a file. The City may have posted it up to an hour earlier.
Read the full official text

WHEREAS, in November 2020 Portland voters approved a ballot measure, with 81.58% in favor, creating a new police accountability and oversight system, adding it to the Charter as Chapter 2-10; andWHEREAS, in October 2024 the Portland City Commission adopted Ordinance 191892, which amended City Code, creating Title 35, "Community Police Oversight Board"; this defined processes for appointments and reappointments to the Community Board for Police Accountability (CBPA); andWHEREAS, of 118 eligible applications in 2025, City Council appointed 21 members and 6 alternates to the CBPA; andWHEREAS, due to membership changes during the training and background and eligibility check period, there are 2 vacant member positions and 3 remaining alternates; andWHEREAS, the Community Board for Police Accountability is scheduled to hold its first meeting on February 11, 2026, at 6 PM; andWHEREAS, due to the time elapsed between the June 18, 2025 appointments and first meeting on February 11, 2026, it is necessary to update term start and end dates for CBPA members, particularly those whose terms would otherwise expire within four months of the CBPA starting to meet.NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that Council appoints alternates Erica (Atticus) Sommerfeld, and Sara Citrenbaum to one-year terms as members of the Community Board for Police Accountability, as noted below and reflected in Exhibit A; andBE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that Community Board for Police Accountability member and alternate term lengths are adjusted to reflect term the beginning meeting date of February 11, 2026 and term length as noted below; andBE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the City Council requests that the Community Board for Police Accountability's volunteer membership begin reporting quarterly to the Council in the second quarter of calendar year 2026; andBE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the City Council requests that the City Operations Service Area support the Community Board for Police Accountability recruitment process by evaluating all remaining applicants deemed eligible and reviewed and scored by the Nominating Committee in the 2025 recruitment process, and return to City Council (or relevant committee) with candidates for Council to appoint by resolution to fill the vacant alternate positions; andBE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the City Council commits to supporting the Community Board for Police Accountability in meeting the deadlines assigned to the City under federal law including the Settlement Agreement, state law including collective bargaining commitments, city law including the City Charter and City Code, and all other applicable requirements.Membership ChangesAlternate Appointed as MemberTerm Start DateTerm End DatePrevious MemberSara CitrenbaumFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2027Karly EdwardsErica (Atticus) SommerfeldFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2027CharlieMichelle-WestleyMemberTerm Start DatePrevious Term End DateNew Term End DateTimothy PittsFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2028February 10, 2029Corinne FrechetteFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2027February 10, 2028Full MembershipNameMember/AlternateTerm Start DateTerm End DateMurtaza BatlaMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2029Justice BrooksMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2029Ash JimenezMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2029Tida Lane-HoweMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2029Tim O'DonnellMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2029Timothy PittsMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2029Dina RossMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2029Kyle AshbyMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2028Corinne FrechetteMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2028Schuyler (Hugh) HalseyMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2028Gillian HerreraMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2028Shelley MaddoxMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2028Jesse NeilsenMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2028Benedikt SpringerMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2028Madeline CarrollMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2027Sara CitrenbaumMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2027Trish GarnerMember February 11, 2026 February 10, 2027Terrence HayesMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2027Pete La RausMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2027Natisha PrattMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2027Erica (Atticus) SommerfeldMemberFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2027Todd BatemanAlternateFebruary 11, 2026February 10, 2029

Meeting history2 meetings · 2 votes
Adopted as amendedAgenda item 11

Motion to amend the Ordinance and replace Exhibit A as shown in Kanal 1: Moved by Kanal and seconded by Dunphy. (Aye (10): Avalos, Smith, Kanal, Pirtle-Guiney, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Clark, Green, Dunphy; Absent (2): Ryan, Zimmerman)

Read all 1 exact motions
Feb 12, 2026 · Amendment · Recorded

Motion to amend the Ordinance and replace Exhibit A as shown in Kanal 1: Moved by Kanal and seconded by Dunphy. (Aye (10): Avalos, Smith, Kanal, Pirtle-Guiney, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Clark, Green, Dunphy; Absent (2): Ryan, Zimmerman)

Latest recorded vote shown above
Meeting-level motion or recommendation · Feb 12, 202610 yes · 2 absent

Motion to amend the Ordinance and replace Exhibit A as shown in Kanal 1: Moved by Kanal and seconded by Dunphy. (Aye (10): Avalos, Smith, Kanal, Pirtle-Guiney, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Clark, Green, Dunphy; Absent (2): Ryan, Zimmerman)

About this recordSource checks & change history

0 human-reviewed findings are linked to this record. Unreviewed machine-extracted fragments are not presented as findings.

Technical information-completeness check · Ready With Caveats · Rules v2

This checks whether decision-relevant categories appear in the published packet. It does not recommend approval or opposition.

Decision definition

The official title and operative text identify the requested action.

Complete
Official legal text

Official text was found. This check does not certify that every referenced exhibit is complete.

Complete
Financial impact

The official impact statement includes financial information.

Complete
Funding source

The impact statement identifies funding information without an explicit unresolved-source qualifier.

Complete
Supporting documents

2 linked supporting documents found; presence alone does not verify their internal completeness.

Complete
Referenced exhibit integrity

The text references exhibits. This guide has not yet automatically verified that each referenced exhibit is present, populated, and internally consistent.

Unknown
Counterparty acceptance

The reviewed action is not expressly identified as a non-binding agreement.

Not Applicable
Implementation

An implementation owner or milestone was not found deterministically.

Unknown
Document stability

Stability requires at least two observed snapshots; the system will update this after another ingestion.

Unknown
Source record
First discovered
Aug 13, 2026, 1:07 PM PDT
Last checked
Nov 13, 2026, 1:29 AM PST
Evidence hash
ea9040e77110215c
Guide status
Deterministic baseline
Append-only timeline
  1. SOURCE UPDATED

    Adopted as amended by council

  2. DOCUMENT PUBLISHED

    Observed in the official source.

  3. Council Action

    Adopted as amended

  4. Council Action

    Rescheduled

Independent guide by Portland Civic Lab. Official City records are authoritative. Votes alone do not establish a Councilor’s reasons.