Report2026-144

Consider appeal by Pleasant Valley Neighborhood Association against the Hearings Officer’s decision to approve with conditions a Planned Development, Land Division and…

The path so far

Each stop is a meeting in the official record, with the City’s own words for what happened.

  1. Tentatively deny appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer's decision and conditions of approval, with revised findingsMeeting guide
  2. Findings adoptedMeeting guide
  3. Where it standsFiled; no final action yet

In brief

From the official impact statement

The Hearings Officer's approval of the proposed development was appealed by the Pleasant Valley Neighborhood Association. Zoning Code Section 33.730.030.G provides that Type III land use review decisions may be appealed to City Council. A Type III land use review appeal is a quasi-judicial action.

Official impact statement

Proposal details

From the official record
Who is affected

This is an appeal of a Type III quasi-judicial land use review, not legislation. The notification procedures for this Type III land use review followed the public notice requirements contained within the Portland Zoning Code, as adopted by the City Council.For Type III land use reviews, the Zoning Code requires public notice of the initial public hearing to be mailed to recognized neighborhood and business associations that are within 1,000 feet of the subject site and to neighbors within 400 feet of the site. In addition, signs notifying the public of the initial hearing were posted at the subject site. City Bureaus were also sent notice. Interested persons were encouraged to write and/or testify at the public hearing conducted before the Hearings Officer.The public hearing before the Hearings Officer took place on February 4, 2026. On February 19, 2026, the Hearings Officer issued a written decision on the proposal (approval with conditions).The City Council decision on the appeal will be the final decision of the City, per Zoning Code Section 33.730.030.I.9. However, the City Council's decision may be appealed to the Oregon Land Use Board of Appeals (LUBA).

Official community impact statement
Financial impact

This is an appeal of a Type III quasi-judicial land use review, not legislation. The City Council decision on this matter will not have financial or budgetary impacts on the City.Land use reviews and appeals are fee supported. City costs associated with this appeal are for staff time to process the appeal.

Official financial impact statement
Prosper Portland analysis

An Economic and Real Estate Development Impact Analysis was not submitted for this proposed action. Pursuant to City Council Resolution 37664, Prosper Portland staff has reviewed the action and agree that it does not require an Economic and Real Estate Development Impact Analysis.

Economic and real estate development analysis, provided by Prosper Portland

Recorded action

Meeting-level motion or recommendation

Recorded · 8–1

Motion to tentatively deny appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer's decision and conditions of approval, with revised findings: Moved by Green and seconded by Ryan. (Aye (8): Kanal, Pirtle-Guiney, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Green, Zimmerman; Nay (1): Dunphy; Absent (3): Clark, Avalos, Smith) Prepare findings for May 13, 2026, at 2:00 p.m. time certain.

Sources & history

Documents1

Official title: Consider appeal by Pleasant Valley Neighborhood Association against the Hearings Officer’s decision to approve with conditions a Planned Development, Land Division and Environmental Review for the creation of 12 single-dwelling lots and 1 multi-dwelling lot in the Pleasant Valley Neighborhood (LU 23-003731 LDS EN PD)

Report 2026-144Current proposal · Portland.gov
Read the full official text

TO THE COUNCIL:The purpose of this memorandum is to provide a brief description of the land use review decision that was appealed, and which will be presented to you in a public hearing on April 23, 2026, at 2:00 pm. Site Location: Vacant parcel SW of 6925 SE 152nd AvenuePP&D Representative: Diane Hale, City Planner II Land Use Review Requested: Type III Planned Development, Land Division and Environmental Review for the creation of 12 single-dwelling lots and 1 multi-dwelling lot.Proposal: The applicant is proposing to divide a vacant, 10.3-acre site into 12 single-dwelling lots (Lots 1, 2 and 4-13) and 1 oversized lot for multi-dwelling development that will consist of nine detached units with a shared driveway and a common open area (Lot 3). The total developed area is 3.6 acres with a maximum of 33 total new dwelling units. A new public street (SE Bybee Drive) and a new private street (SE Odgen Ct.) are proposed to serve the new development. Most of the proposed single dwelling lots are slightly smaller than the zoning code standards for the R10 zone, so the applicant can cluster development outside of the environmental zones to better protect the environmental resources within those zones. Environmental Review is required because environmental standards for land divisions and planned developments are not met. The total proposed permanent disturbance in the Environmental Zones is 185 square feet. Tract C (6.77 acres) is an Environmental Resource tract that will be owned in common by the future homeowners in the subdivision. The Environmental Resource tract is required for environmental preservation; residential development is not allowed in the resource tract.Hearings Officer Decision: The Hearings Officer found that with the conditions of approval listed in the decision, the applicable approval criteria for the Planned Development, Land Division and Environmental Reviews were met. The Hearings Officer approved the proposal with conditions. Appeal: The Pleasant Valley Neighborhood Association appealed the approval decision with the following statement: The Transportation Impact Study limited its crash analysis to subject intersections and did not evaluate SE Barbara Welch Road as the primary corridor serving the site. The City accepted this limited scope without explaining why corridor-level crash history was not relevant to 33.641.020's safety evaluation factor. The City's findings demonstrate reliance on Level of Service and capacity metrics but do not explain how documented corridor safety concerns raised in testimony were evaluated under the safety factor of 33.641.020.Alternatives Facing Council: Deny the appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer's decision and conditions of approval, with revised findings.Deny the appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer's decision, but with revised conditions and findings. Grant the appeal and overturn the Hearings Officer's decision to approve the application, with revised findings.

Meeting history2 meetings · 2 votes
Findings adoptedAgenda item 4

Motion to deny the appeal, uphold the decision of the Hearings Officer, and adopt the findings: Moved by Ryan and seconded by Kanal.

Tentatively deny appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer's decision and conditions of approval, with revised findingsAgenda item 11

Evidentiary record is closed. No further verbal or written testimony will be accepted. Motion to tentatively deny appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer's decision and conditions of approval, with revised findings: Moved by Green and seconded by Ryan. (Aye (8): Kanal, Pirtle-Guiney, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Green, Zimmerman; Nay (1): Dunphy; Absent (3): Clark, Avalos, Smith) Prepare findings for May 13, 2026, at 2:00 p.m. time certain.

Read all 2 exact motions
May 13, 2026 · Main · Recorded

Motion to deny the appeal, uphold the decision of the Hearings Officer, and adopt the findings: Moved by Ryan and seconded by Kanal.

Apr 23, 2026 · Main · Recorded

Motion to tentatively deny appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer's decision and conditions of approval, with revised findings: Moved by Green and seconded by Ryan. (Aye (8): Kanal, Pirtle-Guiney, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Green, Zimmerman; Nay (1): Dunphy; Absent (3): Clark, Avalos, Smith) Prepare findings for May 13, 2026, at 2:00 p.m. time certain.

Latest recorded vote shown above
Recorded vote · Not yet scheduled8 yes · 1 no · 3 absent

Final action on 2026-144: Consider appeal by Pleasant Valley Neighborhood Association against the Hearings Officer’s decision to approve with conditions a Planned Development, Land Division and Environmental Review for the creation of 12 single-dwelling lots and 1 multi-dwelling lot in the Pleasant Valley Neighborhood (LU 23-003731 LDS EN PD)

About this recordSource checks & change history

0 human-reviewed findings are linked to this record. Unreviewed machine-extracted fragments are not presented as findings.

Technical information-completeness check · Ready With Caveats · Rules v2

This checks whether decision-relevant categories appear in the published packet. It does not recommend approval or opposition.

Decision definition

The official title and operative text identify the requested action.

Complete
Official legal text

Official text was found. This check does not certify that every referenced exhibit is complete.

Complete
Financial impact

The official impact statement includes financial information.

Complete
Funding source

The impact statement identifies funding information without an explicit unresolved-source qualifier.

Complete
Supporting documents

No linked attachments were found on the official page.

Unknown
Referenced exhibit integrity

No explicit exhibit reference was detected in the official text.

Not Applicable
Counterparty acceptance

The reviewed action is not expressly identified as a non-binding agreement.

Not Applicable
Implementation

An implementation owner or milestone was not found deterministically.

Unknown
Document stability

Stability requires at least two observed snapshots; the system will update this after another ingestion.

Unknown
Source record
First discovered
Aug 13, 2026, 1:05 PM PDT
Last checked
Nov 13, 2026, 1:26 AM PST
Evidence hash
35e2f83004cbaeb0
Guide status
Deterministic baseline
Append-only timeline
  1. SOURCE UPDATED

    Findings adopted

  2. DOCUMENT PUBLISHED

    Observed in the official source.

  3. Council Action

    Findings adopted

  4. Council Action

    Tentatively deny appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer's decision and conditions of approval, with revised findings

Independent guide by Portland Civic Lab. Official City records are authoritative. Votes alone do not establish a Councilor’s reasons.