Passed · 8–2
Final action on 2025-045: Amend Affordable Housing Code to add prohibition of anti-competitive rental practices including the sale and use of algorithmic devices (add Code Section 30.01.088)
Each stop is a meeting in the official record, with the City’s own words for what happened.
Impacted Communities: Algorithmic rental price-fixing software can drive rent increases, and low-income renters, Black and Indigenous communities, seniors, and disabled individuals are disproportionately affected by rent increases because they tend to be more rent-burdened.This ordinance helps stabilize housing costs and reduce displacement, benefiting rent-burdened families and historically marginalized communities. Neighborhood & Livability Impacts: Rising rents and corporate price-fixing have contributed to increased gentrification and displacement, challenges with which Portland has struggled, particularly in East Portland and historically Black neighborhoods.By banning algorithmic rental price-fixing, this ordinance ensures that housing affordability remains a priority for all Portlanders. Public Engagement & Testimony: Tenant advocacy groups, nonprofit housing organizations, and legal experts have been involved in shaping this ordinance.Small landlords and independent property owners have expressed support, noting that algorithmic pricing primarily benefits large corporate landlords at the expense of renters and smaller property owners.Expected testimony will include representatives from tenant rights organizations, housing justice organizations, and impacted renters who have experienced drastic rent hikes due to algorithm-driven rent increases.
Official community impact statementNo anticipated financial impact on the City’s budget, unless the Council allocates additional resources (i) to the City Attorney’s Office for enforcement, as compliance will primarily be upheld through civil penalties and tenant-initiated legal actions, or (ii) to the Portland Housing Bureau for policy education, outreach, and evaluation to enhance compliance and determine if the policy’s goals are being met.Potential fiscal benefits include:Reducing homelessness and eviction-related costs, which place a burden on social services, emergency housing, and public health resources.Preventing artificially inflated rental prices that contribute to the overall cost of living crisis in Portland.
Official financial impact statementAs the number of potential violations and their durations are unknown at the moment, the amount of resources needed by the City to enforce the language in the code is also unknown, as well as the amount of revenues that may be generated via civil penalties. Enforcement includes the involvement of the City Attorney and the Code Hearings Officer. Civil penalties charged to violators are up to $1,000 per violation, with each month that a landlord charges rent in violation constituting a violation, as well as each month that an entity provides or receives information in violation also constituting a separate violation.There is no currently no financial impact on the City’s budget, as City Council has not allocated additional resources to the City Attorney’s Office for enforcement, as compliance will primarily be upheld through civil penalties and tenant-initiated legal actions, nor to the Portland Housing Bureau for policy education, outreach, and evaluation to enhance compliance and determine if the policy’s goals are being met.Potential fiscal benefits to the City include reducing costs associated with homelessness and evictions, which place a burden on social services, emergency housing, and public health resources.
Financial and budget analysis, provided by City Budget OfficeIn the Portland, Vancouver, Hillsboro metro area, the share of multifamily housing units managed by companies named in rent-setting lawsuits is 16%, with multiple units located outside of the City of PortlandWithout further data gathering about the specific number of companies utilizing the software in Portland and the associated housing units that are currently managed by the aforementioned software, specific economic and development impacts cannot be forecasted. But given base level knowledge, it is reasonable to consider the following potential impacts:Should the ban be approved, landlords will continue to access and use market comparable rent data via published market reports, setting competitive rents in the manner that was done before algorithmic technology was introducedProposed regulation introduces an additional policy restriction and could cause additional risk for the Portland housing market, amplifying already existing reputational concerns while negatively impacting Portland’s delivery of market rate (and related inclusionary housing) unit production. Real estate investors considering investing in housing development, fearing increased risk and potential legal liability, may continue to be discouraged from investing in the city.
Economic and real estate development analysis, provided by Prosper PortlandFinal action on 2025-045: Amend Affordable Housing Code to add prohibition of anti-competitive rental practices including the sale and use of algorithmic devices (add Code Section 30.01.088)
Official title: Amend Affordable Housing Code to add prohibition of anti-competitive rental practices including the sale and use of algorithmic devices (add Code Section 30.01.088)
Ordinance 192122Final official action · Portland.govThe City of Portland ordains.Section 1. The Council finds:The City of Portland recognizes that the sale or use of certain revenue management software programs, known as algorithmic devices, in the rental housing market poses a significant threat to fair competition, housing affordability, and tenant protections.Algorithmic devices enable landlords to indirectly coordinate rental prices and occupancy levels by analyzing and sharing non-public competitor data, leading to artificially inflated rents and reduced housing access.Such practices disproportionately harm low-income residents, increase eviction rates, and destabilize Portland's housing market.Multiple lawsuits, including those filed by the Attorneys General of Arizona[1], United States Department of Justice[2], Multidistrict Litigation (JPML) has transferred a number of actions to the Middle District of Tennessee[3], and Office of the Attorney General for the District of Columbia[4] have highlighted the anti-competitive and harmful effects of these practices.To safeguard tenants, promote fair competition, and ensure market stability, this ordinance prohibits the use and sale of algorithmic devices for setting rents or managing occupancy levels in the City of Portland.NOW, THEREFORE, the Council directs:Add City Code Section 30.01.088 as shown in Exhibit A.This ordinance takes effect 90 days after passage by Council.[1]Attorney General Mayes Sues RealPage and Residential Landlords for Illegal Price-Fixing Conspiracy | Arizona Attorney General[2] Office of Public Affairs | Justice Department Sues RealPage for Algorithmic Pricing Scheme that Harms Millions of American Renters | United States Department of Justice[3] MDL Case Information | Middle District of Tennessee | United States District Court[4] Attorney General Schwalb Sues RealPage & Residential Landlords for Rental Price-Fixing, Illegally Raising Thousands of District Residents’ Rents
Motion to move Pirtle-Guiney/Dunphy amendment 1: Moved by Pirtle-Guiney and seconded by Dunphy. Motion to divide the amendment to consider small landlord exemption separately (C.1.a.1 and E.3): Moved by Kanal. Vote called on technical elements of amendment: (Aye (7): Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Kanal, Morillo, Pirtle-Guiney; Nay (2): Clark, Ryan; Absent (3): Smith, Koyama Lane, Novick) Vote called on small landlord exemption portion of amendment: (Aye (10): Clark, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Smith, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Pirtle-Guiney; Nay (1): Kanal; Absent (1): Novick) Passed to second reading as amended November 19, 2025 at 6:00 p.m.
Motion to replace Exhibit A as shown in the proposed amendment dated October 2, 2025: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Avalos. (Aye (3): Dunphy, Morillo, Avalos; Nay (1): Ryan; Absent (1): Zimmerman) Motion to send Ordinance, Document Number 2025-045, as amended, to the full Council with the recommendation to pass: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Avalos. (Aye (3): Dunphy, Morillo, Avalos; Nay (1): Ryan; Absent (1): Zimmerman)
Motion to refer item back to the Homelessness and Housing Committee: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Koyama Lane. (Aye (12): Kanal, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Clark, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Smith, Pirtle-Guiney)
Motion to discuss the amendment: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Novick. (Aye (10): Kanal, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Clark, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Smith; Nay (2): Ryan, Pirtle-Guiney) Motion to vote on the amendment to Exhibit A: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Smith. (Aye (11): Kanal, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Smith, Pirtle-Guiney; Absent (1) Clark) Motion to amend Exhibit A to update the definition of public date to add ", including, but not limited to, information": Moved by Novick and seconded by Kanal. (Aye (12): Kanal, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Clark, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Smith, Pirtle-Guiney) Passed to second reading as amended April 16, 2025 at 9:30 a.m.
Continued to April 3, 2025 at 3:30 p.m. Existing registrants who have not testified may testify at the meeting, however verbal testimony is closed for new registrations.
Motion to adopt the amendments to the ordinance, Document Number 2025-045: Moved by Dunphy and seconded by Avalos. (Aye (3): Morillo, Dunphy, Avalos; Nay (1): Zimmerman; Absent (1): Ryan) Motion to send the Ordinance, Document Number 2025-045 as amended to the full Council for consideration: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Dunphy.(Aye (3): Morillo, Dunphy, Avalos; Nay (1): Zimmerman; Absent (1): Ryan)
Motion to move Pirtle-Guiney/Dunphy amendment 1: Moved by Pirtle-Guiney and seconded by Dunphy.
Motion to divide the amendment to consider small landlord exemption separately (C.1.a.1 and E.3): Moved by Kanal. Vote called on technical elements of amendment: (Aye (7): Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Kanal, Morillo, Pirtle-Guiney; Nay (2): Clark, Ryan; Absent (3): Smith, Koyama Lane, Novick) Vote called on small landlord exemption portion of amendment: (Aye (10): Clark, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Smith, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Pirtle-Guiney; Nay (1): Kanal; Absent (1): Novick) Passed to second reading as amended November 19, 2025 at 6:00 p.m.
Motion to replace Exhibit A as shown in the proposed amendment dated October 2, 2025: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Avalos. (Aye (3): Dunphy, Morillo, Avalos; Nay (1): Ryan; Absent (1): Zimmerman)
Motion to send Ordinance, Document Number 2025-045, as amended, to the full Council with the recommendation to pass: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Avalos. (Aye (3): Dunphy, Morillo, Avalos; Nay (1): Ryan; Absent (1): Zimmerman)
Motion to refer item back to the Homelessness and Housing Committee: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Koyama Lane. (Aye (12): Kanal, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Clark, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Smith, Pirtle-Guiney)
Motion to discuss the amendment: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Novick. (Aye (10): Kanal, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Clark, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Smith; Nay (2): Ryan, Pirtle-Guiney)
Motion to vote on the amendment to Exhibit A: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Smith. (Aye (11): Kanal, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Smith, Pirtle-Guiney; Absent (1) Clark)
Motion to amend Exhibit A to update the definition of public date to add ", including, but not limited to, information": Moved by Novick and seconded by Kanal. (Aye (12): Kanal, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Clark, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Smith, Pirtle-Guiney) Passed to second reading as amended April 16, 2025 at 9:30 a.m.
Motion to adopt the amendments to the ordinance, Document Number 2025-045: Moved by Dunphy and seconded by Avalos. (Aye (3): Morillo, Dunphy, Avalos; Nay (1): Zimmerman; Absent (1): Ryan)
Motion to send the Ordinance, Document Number 2025-045 as amended to the full Council for consideration: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Dunphy.(Aye (3): Morillo, Dunphy, Avalos; Nay (1): Zimmerman; Absent (1): Ryan)
Motion to replace Exhibit A as shown in the proposed amendment dated October 2, 2025: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Avalos. (Aye (3): Dunphy, Morillo, Avalos; Nay (1): Ryan; Absent (1): Zimmerman)
Motion to send Ordinance, Document Number 2025-045, as amended, to the full Council with the recommendation to pass: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Avalos. (Aye (3): Dunphy, Morillo, Avalos; Nay (1): Ryan; Absent (1): Zimmerman)
Motion to refer item back to the Homelessness and Housing Committee: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Koyama Lane. (Aye (12): Kanal, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Clark, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Smith, Pirtle-Guiney)
Motion to discuss the amendment: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Novick. (Aye (10): Kanal, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Clark, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Smith; Nay (2): Ryan, Pirtle-Guiney)
Motion to vote on the amendment to Exhibit A: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Smith. (Aye (11): Kanal, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Smith, Pirtle-Guiney; Absent (1) Clark)
Motion to amend Exhibit A to update the definition of public date to add ", including, but not limited to, information": Moved by Novick and seconded by Kanal. (Aye (12): Kanal, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Clark, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Dunphy, Smith, Pirtle-Guiney) Passed to second reading as amended April 16, 2025 at 9:30 a.m.
Motion to adopt the amendments to the ordinance, Document Number 2025-045: Moved by Dunphy and seconded by Avalos. (Aye (3): Morillo, Dunphy, Avalos; Nay (1): Zimmerman; Absent (1): Ryan)
Motion to send the Ordinance, Document Number 2025-045 as amended to the full Council for consideration: Moved by Morillo and seconded by Dunphy.(Aye (3): Morillo, Dunphy, Avalos; Nay (1): Zimmerman; Absent (1): Ryan)
0 human-reviewed findings are linked to this record. Unreviewed machine-extracted fragments are not presented as findings.
This checks whether decision-relevant categories appear in the published packet. It does not recommend approval or opposition.
The official title and operative text identify the requested action.
Official text was found. This check does not certify that every referenced exhibit is complete.
The official impact statement includes financial information.
The impact statement identifies funding information without an explicit unresolved-source qualifier.
No linked attachments were found on the official page.
The text references exhibits. This guide has not yet automatically verified that each referenced exhibit is present, populated, and internally consistent.
The reviewed action is not expressly identified as a non-binding agreement.
A direction, reporting requirement, or deadline appears in the official text.
Stability requires at least two observed snapshots; the system will update this after another ingestion.
Passed as amended by council
Observed in the official source.
Passed as amended
Passed to second reading as amended
Referred to City Council as amended
Referred to committee
Passed to second reading as amended
Continued
Referred to City Council as amended
Continued
Independent guide by Portland Civic Lab. Official City records are authoritative. Votes alone do not establish a Councilor’s reasons.