Consider an appeal by the Hillsdale Neighborhood Association requesting to add conditions of approval to the Hearings Officer’s decision to approve the rebuilding of…
The request is not for a legislative action. The request is to consider an appeal by the Hillsdale Neighborhood Association of the Hearings Officer's decision on a Type III quasi-judicial land use review to rebuild Ida B Wells High School. The Hearings Officer's decision was approval with conditions. Staff will be presenting the Hearings Officer's decision at the hearing.Quasi-judicial procedures described in Zoning Code Chapter 33.730, commonly known as land use reviews, are handled by Portland Permitting & Development. Quasi-judicial procedures assign the City Council as the decision-making body for appeals of Type III land use review decisions, per 33.730.030.G.
The standard public involvement procedures for a Type III land use review process have been followed. Prior to the initial public hearing conducted by the Hearings Officer, public notice was mailed to recognized neighborhood and business associations that are within 1,000 feet of the subject site and to property owners within 400 feet of the site. In addition, signs notifying the public of the initial hearing were posted at the subject site. The Hearings Officer then held a public hearing for this application on July 22, 2026, and issued a written decision of approval with conditions after the public record for the hearing was closed. The Hillsdale Neighborhood Association filed an appeal of the Hearings Officer's decision within the appeal period following the issuance of the Hearings Officer's decision.
This is not a legislative action. There are no costs to the City associated with this quasi-judicial land use review. The City resources necessary to process land use review applications are covered by the land use review fees paid by the applicant.
An Economic and Real Estate Development Impact Analysis was not submitted for this proposed action. Pursuant to City Council Resolution 37664, Prosper Portland staff has reviewed the action and agree that it does not require an Economic and Real Estate Development Impact Analysis.
No fiscal impact as this is not a legislative action. There are no costs to the City associated with this quasi-judicial land use review. The City resources necessary to process land use review applications are covered by the land use review fees paid by the applicant.
Motion to tentatively deny the appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer's decision and conditions of approval with the addition of the condition of approval as proposed by the applicant. Direct staff to return at a date and time certain with revised findings: Moved by Zimmerman and seconded by Smith. (Aye (12): Clark, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Smith, Kanal, Pirtle-Guiney, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Dunphy). Continued to November 5, 2026, at 2:30 pm time certain.
5 files of 10 posted to this record have a plain summary. 30 factual statements were compared with the rest of the record. 1 differs from another official passage. 17 match another document. 5 cite an outside source. 7 name no source.
The file presents City Council findings and a decision on the Hillsdale Neighborhood Association’s appeal over rebuilding Ida B. Wells High School. It says Council rejected the appeal while keeping the project approval and adding a condition for limited public access. The document allows public use of specified recreational facilities, subject to conflicting school uses, reservations, and closures for vandalism, emergencies or safety incidents.
3 matches the record
1 conflicts with the record
5 cites an outside source
1 no source given
Read the 10 statements checked
Matches the record
The findings say Council rejected the appeal on November 5, 2026, upholding the Hearings Officer’s decision with a new condition.
The file says
On November 5, 2026, the City Council again voted to reject the
appeal and uphold the decision of the Hearings Officer with the new condition of approval.
On November 5, 2026, the City Council
again voted to reject the appeal and uphold the decision of the Hearings Officer
with the new condition of approval.
The findings say a person appealing to the Oregon Land Use Board of Appeals must have submitted written testimony during the City’s land use review.
The file says
Among other things, ORS 197.830 requires that a petitioner at LUBA
must have submitted written testimony during the comment period or this land use review.
Among other things, ORS 197.830 requires
that a petitioner at LUBA must have appeared orally or in writing during the City’s
proceedings on this land review.
The findings require written testimony, while the Order of Council says appearing orally or in writing qualifies.
Source named in the file: ORS 197.830.
Matches the record
The findings say the modernization will generate no new trips to or from the campus.
The file says
The City Council finds that, based on the unrefuted evidence in the record, the Ida B. Wells
modernization project results in no new trips and no change in capacity.
In
fact, the City in open record testimony acknowledged that the modernization will not generate
additional trips and that based on a consideration of impacts and proportionality, sidewalk
improvements on SW Burlingame would not be warranted.
The findings say Portland Public Schools plans a new 289,500-square-foot high school building along SW Vermont Street.
The file says
Portland Public Schools plans to replace the existing Ida B. Wells High School building
with a new 289,500-square-foot building along SW Vermont Street.
Portland Public Schools plans to replace the existing Ida B. Wells High School building
with a new 289,500-square-foot building along SW Vermont Street.
No source is named in the file. This does not mean the statement is wrong.
Cites an outside source
The findings say the replacement school will have capacity for 1,700 students, the same as the existing school.
The file says
As noted on Page 34 of the traffic study, PP&D Transportation did not require the applicant to
study street capacity or take observational data to determine level of service because the project
does not increase enrollment and trip generation is expected to remain comparable to existing
conditions. The school has 1,690 students enrolled in the 2024-2025 school year. The proposed
replacement school building will have a capacity for 1,700 students, which is the same capacity as
the existing school.
Source named in the file: traffic study. This site has not checked it.
Cites an outside source
The findings say parking surveys found average occupancy of 76 percent during a typical school day.
The file says
Page 35 of the TIS states, “The average of two days of parking surveys showed that 76
percent of these parking stalls are occupied during a typical school day (290 parking stalls).”
Source named in the file: TIS. This site has not checked it.
Cites an outside source
The findings say the applicant’s noise study shows amplified sound can stay below 55 decibels at neighboring residential property lines.
The file says
Council finds that the applicant submitted a professional noise study which details how
the PA systems will comply with Portland Noise Control Code (Title 18) requirements that limit
noise from amplified sources to 55 decibels (comparable to the sound level of a typical
dishwasher) at the lot lines of neighboring residential properties (Exhibit A-25). The noise
study demonstrates that the amplified system will be capable of a decibel level below 55
decibels at the lot lines of neighboring residential properties.
Source named in the file: Exhibit A-25. This site has not checked it.
Cites an outside source
The findings say lighting analyses predict glare at all neighboring property lines significantly below 0.5 foot candles.
The file says
Council finds that the applicant submitted photometric analyses (Exhibits A-16 and A-29)
demonstrating that glare from lights at the lot lines of all neighboring properties would be
significantly lower than 0.5 foot candles, which is the maximum allowed by Zoning Code
Section 33.262.080.A.
Source named in the file: Exhibit A-22. This site has not checked it.
Compared with the record page and the City's analyses, Order of Council, Appeal Hearing Public Notice (contains zoning map, site plan, and building elevations). Part of the record was too long to compare.
This file contains an Order of Council and Council Clerk notices about the appeal of the Ida B. Wells High School rebuilding approval. The order says Council rejected the appeal and upheld approval with a new condition. The added condition allows public use of specified recreation facilities outside school hours, with school activities and scheduled uses taking priority.
8 matches the record
Read the 8 statements checked
Matches the record
The order says Council voted on November 5, 2026, to reject the appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer’s decision with a new condition of approval.
The file says
On November 5, 2026, the City Council
again voted to reject the appeal and uphold the decision of the Hearings Officer
with the new condition of approval.
On November 5, 2026, the City Council again voted to reject the
appeal and uphold the decision of the Hearings Officer with the new condition of approval.
The order says Portland Public Schools plans to replace Ida B. Wells High School’s existing building with a new 289,500-square-foot building along SW Vermont Street.
The file says
Portland Public Schools plans to replace the existing Ida B. Wells High School building
with a new 289,500-square-foot building along SW Vermont Street.
Portland Public Schools plans to replace the existing Ida B. Wells High School building
with a new 289,500-square-foot building along SW Vermont Street.
The order says the applicant requests height limits rising from 50 feet to 60 feet for 4 field light poles and from 50 feet to 70 feet for 4 field light poles.
The file says
The applicant requests the following Zoning Code Adjustment with this review:
x Increase the maximum structure height for new athletic field light poles in the OS
and R7 zones from 50 feet to 60 feet for 4 field light poles and from 50 feet to 70
feet for 4 field light poles
Increase the maximum structure height for new athletic field light poles in the OS and R7
zones from 50 feet to 60 feet for 4 field light poles and from 50 feet to 70 feet for 4 field light
poles
The order says the project includes synthetic turf athletic fields with lighting, spectator seating and voice amplification, plus a new health clinic inside the school.
The file says
The project also includes new
synthetic turf athletic fields with lighting, spectator seating, and voice amplification
systems, new accessory structures, fencing, reconfigured parking and circulation, and a
new health clinic within the new school building.
The project also includes new synthetic turf
athletic fields with lighting, spectator seating, and voice amplification systems, new accessory
structures, fencing, reconfigured parking and circulation, and a new health clinic within the new
school building.
The order says Council’s tentative vote was (12-0) to deny the appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer’s decision with a new condition for limited public access to campus fields.
The file says
After accepting public testimony, the City Council
closed the public hearing and voted tentatively (12-0) to deny the appeal and
uphold the Hearings Officer’s decision with one new condition of approval offered
by the applicant related to limited public access to certain fields on the campus.
After accepting public testimony, the City
Council closed the public hearing and voted tentatively (12-0) to deny the appeal and
uphold the Hearings Officer’s decision with one new condition of approval offered by the
applicant related to limited public access to certain fields on the campus.
The presentation proposes public access outside school hours to the Ida B. Wells track and tennis courts and the Rieke softball and multi-use fields. The proposed condition would give school activities and scheduled uses priority over neighborhood access, and allow closures for vandalism, emergencies or safety incidents.
Only 6 of 12 pages had readable text. Scanned pages were not checked.
No source is named in the file. This does not mean the statement is wrong.
Compared with the record page and the City's analyses, Order of Council, Findings and Decision, Appellant presentation. Part of the record was too long to compare.
This presentation from the Hillsdale Neighborhood Association supports replacing Ida B. Wells High School but argues that approval requirements concerning pedestrian, bicycle, and community access are unmet. The slides request conditions allowing bicycle access on Rieke Road, maintaining safe off-street pedestrian access at the Burlingame Road campus entrance, and continuing public access to outdoor campus space.
Only 3 of 5 pages had readable text. Scanned pages were not checked.
This file makes no factual statements that could be compared with the rest of the record.
Compared with the record page and the City's analyses, Order of Council, Findings and Decision, Applicant presentation. Part of the record was too long to compare.
This staff presentation from Portland Permitting & Development explains the appeal over rebuilding Ida B Wells High School. The slides say the neighborhood association seeks changes to approval conditions, rather than rejection of the project. They describe requests for designated bicycle and pedestrian routes, pedestrian improvements on SW Burlingame Ave., and public use of outdoor facilities during non-school hours.
6 matches the record
4 no source given
Read the 10 statements checked
Matches the record
The slides say the neighborhood association seeks changes to approval conditions without overturning the project's approval.
The file says
The appeal is not a request to overturn the Conditional Use
Review approval, but rather a request for changes to the
conditions of approval.
In this appeal, the Hillsdale Neighborhood Association is not asking the City Council to overturn the Hearings Officer's approval of the project. Rather, they are asking the City Council to modify the Hearings Officer's decision to include the following conditions of approval:
In short, the proposal does not expand the existing square footage of
the school facilities, does not expand the capacity of the school and does not add any new
pedestrian or vehicle trips to the site.
No source is named in the file. This does not mean the statement is wrong.
No source given
The slides say recent approvals for rebuilding or substantially remodeling other public high schools did not require open access for neighbors at specified times.
The file says
The City has approved rebuilds or major
remodels for several other public high
schools in recent years, and none of those
land use decisions included a requirement
for open access for neighbors at certain
times.
No source is named in the file. This does not mean the statement is wrong.
No source given
The slides say SW Burlingame Ave. has no sidewalks, so people would still walk in the street to reach a sidewalk built along the school frontage.
The file says
There are no sidewalks on SW
Burlingame Ave., so even if the school
district constructed a sidewalk on their
frontage, people would still have to walk
in the street to reach it.
No source is named in the file. This does not mean the statement is wrong.
Matches the record
The slides say the Hearings Officer required public access easements before a building permit, allowing cyclists to ride outside the fenced area, including on either the Rieke driveway or its adjacent pathway.
The file says
D. Public access easements through the site
must be executed prior to issuance of a
building permit. The public access
easements must allow access for mounted
cyclists outside of the fenced area, including
either the pathway on the east side of the
Rieke driveway or in the drive aisle for the
Rieke driveway.
The public access
easements must be executed and recorded prior to issuance of the building permit
for the school building. The easement agreements will identify the post-construction
effective date of public access as well as other essential terms, such as hours of
operation and emergency closure restrictions, consistent with Exhibit A-30. The
public access easements granted through this project must allow bicycle access for
mounted cyclists for routes outside of the fence line, including either the pathway on
the east side of the Rieke driveway or in the drive aisle for the Rieke driveway.
An Adjustment to increase the maximum structure height for new athletic field light
poles in the OS and R7 zones from 50 feet to 60 feet for 4 field light poles and from 50
feet to 70 feet for 4 field light poles
No source is named in the file. This does not mean the statement is wrong.
Compared with the record page and the City's analyses, Order of Council, Findings and Decision, Appellant presentation. Part of the record was too long to compare.
How to read these labels
Matches the record
Another official document on this record says the same thing. That shows the documents agree. It does not show the statement is true, and the two documents may come from the same office.
Conflicts with the record
Another official passage on this record says something different. Both passages are shown. This site does not decide which one is right.
Differs from its cited source
The document attributes the statement to a source on this record, and that source reads differently. Both passages are shown.
Cites an outside source
The document names a source that is not part of this record. This site has not checked that source.
No source given
The document does not say where the statement comes from, and the record documents this check read do not address it. This does not mean the statement is wrong.
Summaries and labels are written by software and checked by a second automated pass. No person reviewed them before publication. Each label rests on the quoted passages shown with it, and compares a file only with the other official documents on this record. Written testimony from residents is not checked. Every version, including replaced and withdrawn ones, stays public.
Official title: Consider an appeal by the Hillsdale Neighborhood Association requesting to add conditions of approval to the Hearings Officer’s decision to approve the rebuilding of Ida B Wells High School (LU 26-026160 CU AD)
First seen is when this site’s hourly check found a file. The City may have posted it up to an hour earlier. Read the full official text
The purpose of this memorandum is to provide a brief description of the land use review appeal that will be presented to you in a public hearing on October 15, 2026, at 2:00 PM (case file # LU 26-026160 CU AD).Location: The subject site is a 35-acre Portland Public Schools property in the Hillsdale Neighborhood of Southwest Portland containing Ida B Wells High School and Rieke Elementary School. The address is 1151 SW Vermont Street. About: Portland Public Schools proposes to rebuild Ida B Wells High School and make various improvements to the school campus. The proposal requires approval of a Type III Conditional Use Review. The Hearings Officer held a public hearing for this application on July 22, 2026, and issued a written decision of approval with conditions after the public record for the hearing was closed. The Hillsdale Neighborhood Association filed an appeal of the Hearings Officer's decision within the appeal period following the issuance of the Hearings Officer's decision. In this appeal, the Hillsdale Neighborhood Association is not asking the City Council to overturn the Hearings Officer's approval of the project. Rather, they are asking the City Council to modify the Hearings Officer's decision to include the following conditions of approval:To require the north-south public access easement through the center of the site to designate the driveway for cyclists and the pathway next to the driveway for pedestrians, and to require shared lane markings ("sharrows") on the driveway.To require the school district to construct frontage improvements on SW Burlingame Ave. for pedestrians.To require the school district to provide public access without the need for reservations to open areas and recreational facilities on the campus, including the athletic fields, track, practice field, courtyard, and tennis courts, during non-school hours when those areas are not reserved for school activities, athletics, maintenance, or other authorized uses.The full case file and an audio recording of the Hearings Officer hearing are available online at LU 26-026160 CU AD.
Meeting history2 meetings · 2 votes
Findings adoptedAgenda item 15
Motion to deny the appeal, uphold the decision of the Hearings Officer with the additional condition of approval as proposed by the applicant, and adopt the findings: Moved by Dunphy and seconded by Novick.
Tentatively deny appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer's decision and conditions of approval, with revised findingsAgenda item 15
Evidentiary record is closed. No further verbal or written testimony will be accepted.
Motion to tentatively deny the appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer's decision and conditions of approval with the addition of the condition of approval as proposed by the applicant. Direct staff to return at a date and time certain with revised findings: Moved by Zimmerman and seconded by Smith. (Aye (12): Clark, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Smith, Kanal, Pirtle-Guiney, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Dunphy).
Continued to November 5, 2026, at 2:30 pm time certain.
Read all 2 exact motions
Nov 5, 2026 · Main · Recorded
Motion to deny the appeal, uphold the decision of the Hearings Officer with the additional condition of approval as proposed by the applicant, and adopt the findings: Moved by Dunphy and seconded by Novick.
Oct 15, 2026 · Procedural · Continued
Motion to tentatively deny the appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer's decision and conditions of approval with the addition of the condition of approval as proposed by the applicant. Direct staff to return at a date and time certain with revised findings: Moved by Zimmerman and seconded by Smith. (Aye (12): Clark, Green, Zimmerman, Avalos, Smith, Kanal, Pirtle-Guiney, Ryan, Koyama Lane, Morillo, Novick, Dunphy). Continued to November 5, 2026, at 2:30 pm time certain.
Vote register entry for 2026-347: Consider an appeal by the Hillsdale Neighborhood Association requesting to add conditions of approval to the Hearings Officer’s decision to approve the rebuilding of Ida B Wells High School (LU 26-026160 CU AD)
0 human-reviewed findings are linked to this record. Unreviewed machine-extracted fragments are not presented as findings.
Technical information-completeness check · Ready With Caveats · Rules v2
This checks whether decision-relevant categories appear in the published packet. It does not recommend approval or opposition.
Decision definition
The official title and operative text identify the requested action.
Complete
Official legal text
Official text was found. This check does not certify that every referenced exhibit is complete.
Complete
Financial impact
The official impact statement includes financial information.
Complete
Funding source
The impact statement identifies funding information without an explicit unresolved-source qualifier.
Complete
Supporting documents
10 linked supporting documents found; presence alone does not verify their internal completeness.
Complete
Referenced exhibit integrity
No explicit exhibit reference was detected in the official text.
Not Applicable
Counterparty acceptance
The reviewed action is not expressly identified as a non-binding agreement.
Not Applicable
Implementation
An implementation owner or milestone was not found deterministically.
Unknown
Document stability
Stability requires at least two observed snapshots; the system will update this after another ingestion.
Unknown
Source record
First discovered
Nov 12, 2026, 11:07 AM PST
Last checked
Nov 18, 2026, 4:07 PM PST
Evidence hash
6dcb9466e1932a70
Guide status
Deterministic baseline
Append-only timeline
SOURCE UPDATED
Findings adopted
SOURCE UPDATED
Findings adopted on November 5, 2026 by City Council
Council Action
Findings adopted
SOURCE UPDATED
Tentatively deny appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer's decision and conditions of approval, with revised findings on October 15, 2026 by City Council
Council Action
Tentatively deny appeal and uphold the Hearings Officer's decision and conditions of approval, with revised findings
SOURCE UPDATED
Referred to City Council by Council President
DOCUMENT PUBLISHED
Referred to City Council by Council President
Independent guide by Portland Civic Lab. Official City records are authoritative. Votes alone do not establish a Councilor’s reasons.